Quoted from Deaconblooze:I really think games like BBH arcade could have some legs in a collection. My brother has one, and we love playing it. The turns are quick, and it's super simple - it makes it great for a party game (better than pinball, imo).
The issue I'd have with the other gun games mentioned - they're all pretty linear. I know that I'd personally play the shit out of it for about a week, and probably never touch it unless a guest requested to play.
I agree & think theirs a zombie update for BBH! Games like alien and house of the dead are fun although once you beat the 7-10 levels you'll never play it again. BBH is an excellent party game and everyone's always up for a challenge.