(Topic ID: 112929)

Let's figure out the minimum parts to build a whitewood

By Aurich

9 years ago


Topic Heartbeat

Topic Stats

  • 1,883 posts
  • 115 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 1 year ago by MrBigg
  • Topic is favorited by 136 Pinsiders

You

Linked Games

No games have been linked to this topic.

    Topic Gallery

    View topic image gallery

    20221115_175116 (resized).jpg
    20221105_214513 (resized).jpg
    20221025_174630 (resized).jpg
    20221002_125357 (resized).jpg
    20220828_130251 (resized).jpg
    20220815_174618 (resized).jpg
    20220811_190435 (resized).jpg
    b30d187522c0fcc21c8ab9402e12cf9d10f9bb12 (resized).jpg
    E142D237-4481-44F5-A94A-3CC7FE7A71D2 (resized).jpeg
    20170711_204158 (resized).jpg
    20170711_204145 (resized).jpg
    20170711_204208 (resized).jpg
    playfield doodle.jpg
    IMG_0619 (resized).JPG
    IMG_0415 (resized).JPG
    IMG_0407 (resized).JPG
    There are 1,883 posts in this topic. You are on page 17 of 38.
    #801 8 years ago
    Quoted from swinks:

    Has anyone tried this, any thoughts from anyone or those who are experienced surfboard makers

    That's a cool video, but why the hell did he leave that black stripe running through the center of the graphic?????

    #802 8 years ago
    Quoted from toyotaboy:

    Most people do vinyl sticker overlays. Either you cut out the inserts and print an opaque label, or you print a clear label but paint the wood white (since most printers won't print white). It's done all of the time:
    http://pinballmagic.com/index.php?main_page=page&id=6&chapter=0

    I am aware of that technique but heard bad things if you try to clear over it, where resin goes through the rice paper makes it all one

    Quoted from vid1900:

    That's a cool video, but why the hell did he leave that black stripe running through the center of the graphic?????

    that would be the stringer which adds strength to the foam board core.

    #803 8 years ago
    Quoted from swinks:

    that would be the stringer which adds strength to the foam board core.

    I would have painted it white than have a hockey player with a black stripe down his face, lol.

    #804 8 years ago
    Quoted from vid1900:

    I would have painted it white than have a hockey player with a black stripe down his face, lol.

    Good point but surfers see past it I suppose, I didn't notice it because it is a everyday thing but you picked it up

    #805 8 years ago
    Quoted from swinks:

    I am aware of that technique but heard bad things if you try to clear over it, where resin goes through the rice paper makes it all one

    Isn't this how Ben did the first AMH boards? I swear there is a video somewhere of him putting down the graphic. I have no idea if they did this for all of them or not. Knowing how to clear this would be great since I have this exact project coming up fast.

    #806 8 years ago
    Quoted from desertT1:

    Isn't this how Ben did the first AMH boards? I swear there is a video somewhere of him putting down the graphic

    It was for bill paxton

    #807 8 years ago
    Quoted from toyotaboy:

    It was for bill paxton
    » YouTube video

    THANK YOU! I spent a ton of time one day looking for that, but was doing it in the time frame that AMH was getting worked on. No wonder I never found it. Is AMH direct printed, or did they do vinyl overlays of some sort as well?

    #808 8 years ago

    It's my understanding AMH is direct printed, same as the woz cabinets Charlie worked on

    #809 8 years ago

    Design question: When you compare the lanes of, say, TWD and Xmen, what gets moved to allow for the extra inlane on Xmen. I'm assuming the flipper spacing never changes and you can only go so far out, so where does that extra lane come from?

    I thought of this while looking at the Stern PF file.

    #810 8 years ago

    Flippers do move around. For example, that's why FT has the "lightning flippers" on it as the regular length ones made the game too easy due to the flipper gap being smaller.

    But they usually just shorten the ball run to the flippers.

    #811 8 years ago

    But is the spacing different on TWD and XM. I tried to pick two examples that would have more similarities than comparing a Stern to a B/W. I know about the lightning flippers and the CFTBL spacing. I'm really just wondering what shifted when you compare TWD and XM to get the extra inlane. Nothing is jumping out at me. My design has 1 inlane and 1 outlane on either side so I don't really have to worry about shifting anything on the template.

    #812 8 years ago

    You'd probably have to measure but I bet you'd find a difference.

    #813 8 years ago

    I have a comparison tool at work and made a PDF of Tron and TWD PF pictures that were pretty close. Using the comparison... it's way to busy to point out where the differences are.

    Fortunately, I have a friend with a Tron and an IM, so next time I am over there I will measure a few things and try to figure it out.

    #814 8 years ago

    Just look on the VP forums at all the playfield scans if you want to compare empty playfields

    #815 8 years ago

    Usually the slingshots get shrunk a bit, things get shifted over slightly, and sometimes the rail between the right outlane and the plunger lane becomes a thin piece of metal or wire guide rather then a block of wood.

    In the case of x-men, the slings are smaller, everything is shifted to the left ~0.5" or so, and the right inlanes are separated by wire rather then flat sheet metal + plastic.

    So... ~0.5" added by shifting, ~0.5" added by making narrower slingshots (~0.25" from each side), and slightly thiner inlane/outlanes = ~1.1" enough for an extra lane.

    This does result in the flippers not being centred in the playfield (as seen in xmen, tron, ect). If you didn't move the flippers to the left but instead changed the block of wood between the right outlane and plunger lane to a wire, you'd have centred flippers AND room for the 3rd inlane (or 3rd outlane).

    #816 8 years ago

    like what Linolium said check out the new KISS pinball with the flippers more to the right and a wire separating the right outlane and the plunger lane

    #817 8 years ago

    Pure Russian Machinist Porn:

    #818 8 years ago
    Quoted from vid1900:

    Pure Russian Machinist Porn:
    » YouTube video

    Yeah, that was pretty cool. I couldn't figure out what he was doing with the hot glue until the end, then I was like ohhh yeah, right... to make sure it didn't fall/break on/onto the mill end during the last thin cuts.

    I have a CNC router, I wish I had a lathe too. So cool. Machines are addictive.

    edit : wow this thread has really blown up, I have not been on here much for a while. I know a local fella is trying to get people to build prototype machines, but it seems like everyone's going at it these days!

    I've been using a bare Stern Star Trek playfield as a tool to get basic geometry measurements from, I figure if it's good enough for Steve Ritchie, it's good enough for me! The shooter lane had me puzzled for a minute until I just made a cone in solidworks and imported it into Aspire (on its side, subtractive). I still might let Solidworks do the machining on that part then run the rest of the file from Aspire, Aspire isn't quite as good with the 3d toolpathing.

    Anyone here using SolidWorks or Vectric Aspire? I've had some personal stuff keeping me from working as much on my stuff as I've wanted to, then my CNC shit the bed due to some newb mistakes I made during initial assembly (various things), then yesterday my control PC hard drive crapped out. Fewf, one thing after the other but I'm back into it now and the machine is working like a boss.

    #819 8 years ago

    SteveP3,
    I am using Solidworks, BTW, I don't think you can make a cone and subract it from the PF.

    A cone will have a varying radius, You need to take a Circle (constant radius) and sweep it along a path at an angle to the PF.

    I'll do a quick SW part and attach it later.

    #820 8 years ago
    Quoted from vid1900:

    Pure Russian Machinist Porn:
    » YouTube video

    So freaking awesome.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #822 8 years ago

    And of course the Solidworks file will not upload. $%#$## computers.

    I'll go drop it in the 3d section at Pinballmakers....

    #823 8 years ago
    Quoted from BobLangelius:

    And of course the Solidworks file will not upload. $%#$## computers.

    Yeah, I wish Robin would give **trusted** Pinsiders the ability to upload file types like .zip

    #824 8 years ago
    Quoted from vid1900:

    Yeah, I wish Robin would give **trusted** Pinsiders the ability to upload file types like .zip

    I saw what you did in that girls of pinball thread and you cannot be trusted.

    #825 8 years ago

    Shooter lane is pretty easy in SW. There's a bunch of ways to tackle it depending on what you want.

    Most intuitive is to draw a circle and sweep/extrude it at an angle to the PF (or on a curve) like boblangelius did above. In practice this is the most realistic as far as manufacturing goes - the tool has a constant radius and simply rise out of the workpiece as it travels. The minor complaint I have with this is easily controlling the end position of the groove requires a sweep which adds a sketch for the path.

    My preferred method is to do it with a revolve cut feature. You set up a plane on the center of the shooter lane then revolve a cylinder around a centerline at an angle (or revolve a tapered cone around a straight centerline - less realistic manufacturing wise). Choose your diameter and depth at the start, and make it coincident at the end. Easy to dimension, all in a single sketch.

    Revolve2.PNGRevolve2.PNG

    Alternatively you can use a loft cut from a circle to a point and adjust the position of the end point and the "normal to profile" value to adjust your 'cylinder/cone' transition. It's fancy but ultimately kinda cumbersome.

    Loft 2.PNGLoft 2.PNG

    You could also model a solid cone body and use the "Combine Bodies" feature and subtract it from the PF. This would be by far the most cumbersome method imo and is functionally identical to the above methods with the added 'subtraction' feature.

    #826 8 years ago

    Sweep cut is definitely the easiest one IMO. That's what I use.

    #827 8 years ago
    Quoted from BobLangelius:

    SteveP3,
    I am using Solidworks, BTW, I don't think you can make a cone and subract it from the PF.
    A cone will have a varying radius, You need to take a Circle (constant radius) and sweep it along a path at an angle to the PF.
    I'll do a quick SW part and attach it later.

    Thanks for the info. What I was trying to say initially is that as a test I just made a cone in solidworks, exported it as a part; then imported the model into Aspire and used Aspire to subtract it from the playfield wood (there's an inbuilt function for this in Aspire). I only did this because I enjoy using Aspire compared to solidworks for your everyday type of stuff like light holes, any other cutouts, etc.

    I'll have to look into using a more cylindrical model instead and see what i think of that.

    edit multiple days later : ah, I googled pinball makers. Thanks for uploading that file, I now know what you meant by that.

    #828 8 years ago
    Quoted from Purpledrilmonkey:

    (Smart stuff said about shooterlane cutting techniques in solidworks)

    Cool beans, I guess I'll try what you fellas are doing with the cylindrical thing. The cone approach actually did give good results from the point of view of the ball rolling up it with a consistent gap (edit : ie - cradled nicely) - I must have just gotten lucky with my measurements from the playfield I'm using.

    I prefer working in Aspire for almost everything, but I know my way around Solidworks well enough to make a cylinder and export/import to Aspire then go from there. Thanks.

    Edit 2 : Here's my basic template that I've been using so far (the little extra bits in the holes are just waste material), this is using a cone for the shooterlane cutout. I'll post again once I have used the cylinder approach. Thanks guys.

    Playfield Template 1.jpgPlayfield Template 1.jpg

    1 week later
    #829 8 years ago

    This new thing might be interesting for prototyping without going all-in with full CNC.

    #830 8 years ago

    You can build a full size CNC router table for under $4000 (I've built 2 of them):

    http://mechmate.com/

    #831 8 years ago

    auto aligning router: genius. Curious what the price will be

    #832 8 years ago

    I just broke down an entertainment center. While it's particle board, I'm tempted to take a few good pieces from it to make a playfield for an entirely-junk-made playfield and back board(as opposed to backbox). Put the Utilimarc board(s) on the backboard & wire it down to the pf.

    #833 8 years ago
    Quoted from toyotaboy:

    auto aligning router: genius. Curious what the price will be

    Probably nearly as much as the CNC router vid mentioned

    #834 8 years ago
    Quoted from toyotaboy:

    Nice, is that using a 1/4" bit? Can't wait to see it populated to see how things line up.

    Finally attached some stuff. I was waiting for parts and then messing around with the electronics. Things fit pretty well. I need an extra millimeter or so clearance on the flipper feeds, but it would probably be ok if I had the right size rubbers on the slingshots. I drilled for the lane guides by hand as well, so that could be my fault.

    P1000523.jpgP1000523.jpg
    P1000521.jpgP1000521.jpg

    #835 8 years ago

    nice work ecurtz

    #836 8 years ago

    I've figured out what I want to buy from someone.

    I want the bottom part of a playfield CNC'd with all of the "standard" holes, including lane inserts, between the flipper insert, etc....

    But I only want the wood to be long enough to get right past the entrances to the lanes. I'm going to build a side rail system on my playfield rotisserie that basically has the playfield in multiple pieces. That way I can keep messing with the upper part of the playfield without having to have a new lower piece.

    The only thing I can compare it to is like leafs in a dining room table. The leaf on the end is the standard playfield bottom, then I can swap out other panels as I fuck them up or improve them.

    Does that make sense?

    I put a red line on ecurtz's picture to show the piece I want. Everything below it, plus a bunch of holes that his pic doesn't have yet.

    406003_cut.jpg406003_cut.jpg

    #837 8 years ago

    Yeah, that's the most complicated and precise section of the table and doing only part of it would make shipping a lot cheaper as well. I'll probably just slice this one for at least the first few revisions when it gets too messy. Another on my not really saving time/money thoughts - don't bother with MDF. Yeah it's dirt cheap and easy to work with, but it's also nasty and it doesn't cut well. Just start with high quality plywood from the beginning.

    #838 8 years ago
    Quoted from Wolfmarsh:

    I've figured out what I want to buy from someone.
    I want the bottom part of a playfield CNC'd with all of the "standard" holes, including lane inserts, between the flipper insert, etc....
    But I only want the wood to be long enough to get right past the entrances to the lanes. I'm going to build a side rail system on my playfield rotisserie that basically has the playfield in multiple pieces. That way I can keep messing with the upper part of the playfield without having to have a new lower piece.
    The only thing I can compare it to is like leafs in a dining room table. The leaf on the end is the standard playfield bottom, then I can swap out other panels as I fuck them up or improve them.
    Does that make sense?
    I put a red line on ecurtz's picture to show the piece I want. Everything below it, plus a bunch of holes that his pic doesn't have yet.
    406003_cut.jpg (Click image to enlarge)

    That's an interesting idea. I was looking at what I do with my FAST Frame setup and it would be easy to have the lowest 1/3 in place and swap out the upper 2/3. Easily mount it with screws or even just clamp it in place. Kind of a cool way to mock stuff up without having to pay for complete lowest 1/3 every time you are mocking up a game.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #839 8 years ago
    Quoted from ecurtz:

    Just start with high quality plywood from the beginning.

    Great advice! MDF can be a mess. I end up using a hardwood plywood from Home Depot and its not too expensive.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #840 8 years ago

    What about metal templates you can clamp onto any wood pf and cut as one pleases? Maybe introduce some inter-changability(multiple slides you can puzzle-piece in/out) to it so you can customize it to your project.

    #841 8 years ago
    Quoted from s1500:

    What about metal templates you can clamp onto any wood pf and cut as one pleases? Maybe introduce some inter-changability(multiple slides you can puzzle-piece in/out) to it so you can customize it to your project.

    I would love a set of templates like that. I always tell myself "next time you do a playfield, make templates." But I never do. Too anxious to get to the playfield at hand.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #842 8 years ago
    Quoted from fastpinball:

    I would love a set of templates like that. I always tell myself "next time you do a playfield, make templates." But I never do. Too anxious to get to the playfield at hand.

    I was doodling at work(computer was running stuff) and the thought came to my head. You could assemble your dream bottom layout with the metal plates, clamp 'er down, and drill away. Or before you drill out, just move them around to see you have proper clearances so the ball won't get stuck.

    For edge pieces, you could just have a 90-degree bend in the part downward, giving you(hopefully) that just right clearance, at least for the left outlane.

    For a shooter lane, you could just lay it down & use a scratch awl(if no CAD), or a bit more for drill holes for your wooden piece to divide the outlane + shooter lane.

    #843 8 years ago
    Quoted from s1500:

    For a shooter lane, you could just lay it down & use a scratch awl(if no CAD), or a bit more for drill holes for your wooden piece to divide the outlane + shooter lane.

    For my shooter lanes I have been using a high torque drill with a barrel sanding bit on it. I clamped it to a block of wood to make it easier to slide up and down the length of the playfield for a straight shooter lane. Not perfect and certainly took some eyeballing, but it worked for whitewoods.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #844 8 years ago
    Quoted from Wolfmarsh:

    I want the bottom part of a playfield CNC'd with all of the "standard" holes, including lane inserts, between the flipper insert, etc....

    But I only want the wood to be long enough to get right past the entrances to the lanes. I'm going to build a side rail system on my playfield rotisserie that basically has the playfield in multiple pieces. That way I can keep messing with the upper part of the playfield without having to have a new lower piece.

    that's not a bad idea actually, at least for a whitewood. once you get the lower half done, you worry about making mistakes because you're invested. About the only fix if you mess something up is to re-fill it with a matching piece of wood and level it. Hinges would only make minimal gaps (say 1/16"), and the gaps could be filled with a strip of rubber, or just use masking tape.

    #845 8 years ago
    Quoted from toyotaboy:

    that's not a bad idea actually, at least for a whitewood. once you get the lower half done, you worry about making mistakes because you're invested. About the only fix if you mess something up is to re-fill it with a matching piece of wood and level it. Hinges would only make minimal gaps (say 1/16"), and the gaps could be filled with a strip of rubber, or just use masking tape.

    Exactly!

    I don't even know that there would be a gap, I can easily model and 3D print some type of bracket/latch that keeps the center of the two pieces aligned vertically. The rails would clamp down on the sides keeping them aligned.

    It would definitely be easier to ship too. Someone please get on this! I'd like a modern Stern style setup.

    #846 8 years ago
    Quoted from Wolfmarsh:

    Exactly!
    I don't even know that there would be a gap, I can easily model and 3D print some type of bracket/latch that keeps the center of the two pieces aligned vertically. The rails would clamp down on the sides keeping them aligned.
    It would definitely be easier to ship too. Someone please get on this! I'd like a modern Stern style setup.

    I could have cuts produced pretty easily if I had the cut plans. It's been on the long list for a while. I have unpopulated WPC, System 11 and early Bally play fields waiting to be measured and modeled, but haven't been able to get to it yet.

    If I had the cut plans, I could get whatever we want cut.

    Aaron
    FAST Pinball

    #847 8 years ago
    Quoted from Wolfmarsh:

    I don't even know that there would be a gap, I can easily model and 3D print some type of bracket/latch that keeps the center of the two pieces aligned vertically. The rails would clamp down on the sides keeping them aligned.

    Only way to make the gaps disappear would be to recess the hinges (cutouts on the sides). As far as alignment vertically, you could glue hinges temporary in place (let them rest on the surface), and let the pieces lie flat, then go back and add screws for strength.

    Again, I don't think you'd ever want to build a final game this way, it would only be for layout purposes. Once your shots look good, scan the holes, make a DXF, send it out to a CNC router.

    #848 8 years ago

    No need for hinges really. Can just put in some 3D printed brackets like Wolfmarsh was saying that screw into the bottom of the playfield to keep the center aligned and clamps on the sides. The brackets could stay in place on the lower 3rd and then screw into new upper 2/3rd section of whitewood.

    I don't think it would be a perfect gap, but maybe a little work with some light sandpaper or some masking tape or something would be good enough to keep the ball from jumping when it hit the joint.

    #849 8 years ago

    Add some power, a Power Driver 16, Teensy 3.1 and RS485 transceiver...

    P1000527.jpgP1000527.jpg
    Stew_Going.jpgStew_Going.jpg

    #850 8 years ago
    Quoted from vid1900:

    That's a cool video, but why the hell did he leave that black stripe running through the center of the graphic?????

    You use the stripe for reference when surfing. If you look at images of boards, they almost always have longitudinal stripes..

    There are 1,883 posts in this topic. You are on page 17 of 38.

    Reply

    Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.

    Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

    Donate to Pinside

    Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!


    This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/lets-figure-out-the-bare-minimum-costparts-to-build-a-whitewood/page/17 and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.

    Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.