Quoted from beelzeboob:Are you still drooling over this game? Pinside has already moved on to Stage Two of any new game: complaining about the gameplay. We seem to go through this with every new release. POTC didn't have any effect on game values, and this won't either. I'm in for a Zeppelin no matter how "empty" the people on Pinside think it looks...and I know there are a ton of other people who feel the same way.
I get what you're saying. I think you're right that in general new pins don't reduce the value of older ones noticably. I just wanted to say because this affected me personally that when jjp potc was announced and shown the prices of stern potc took a nosedive. I was selling a stern potc at the time and was pretty disappointed my pin was now worth much less. Many people were excited by the JJP pirates when it was first shown and wanted to hold out for the jjp version. Same thing happened with jjp guns and roses, someone on here had a data east gnr for around $3k
Rare case I know, in general new pins don't affect old ones.