For me JJP are all wins big gorgeous graphics.
Batman I won't comment because I haven't see it enough.
Areosmith looks a little too South Park and to me its a fail. Looks cheap and half assed.
Star Wars is also a complete fail for me. Most of the clips are low res taking up like a 1/4 of the screen. Way too much cheap web-quality animations. I don't know the actual metrics but I would love to know what percent of the time is that abysmal cockpit view.
All in all Stern is trying to slap old tech on a new screen. It's like watching a VHS on a modern TV, whats the point?