I will also mention that you say this is purchased from a business.

Like it or not, that adds to the price because a business
1) Needs to make a profit on sales
2) Should offer some sort of after sale support (even if it is just taking a phone call and ensuring it's working once it's set up in your home)
3) Will be taxed on any profits they make on the sale
4) Needs to pay employees (even if it's a one person show... have to pay yourself to fix up the machine)

Based on that, and the fine condition it seems to be in, I think you would be hard pressed to find a similar machine for less than $3500.

Now if you're looking at a private sale, I would think $2700-$3000 is reasonable.

If you find one for $2k anywhere... give them my phone number so I can give them a stern talking to

There's one for sale now in St.Louis for $2500 which I'm surprised hasn't sold (maybe they just didn't take the add down?)... been listed for a long time, so maybe they are negotiable.

https://pinside.com/pinball/market/classifieds/ad/66172

I think it's a fair deal.... you're definitely not getting ripped off at that price

This is good because if anything is going to break it's going to be within the first couple hours of play after you've moved it... things get rattled as it's bumping down the highway.

I once sold a pin to a first time buyer, and by the time she got it home, there were a dozen things not working on it. It had been working perfectly for the 6 months I had it. She drove 6 hours to get it, and we tried out every single switch etc before we loaded it. I tried my best to walk her through what I could but after 3-4 weeks, I had to tell her to get a local pin repair person... once it was loaded in her car, it really isn't my problem any more.

Where are you seeing those prices? On your local craigslist the only pins I see are a $3200 swe1 and a $2800 lah. Have a head time believing that a $2100 jp wouldn’t be snapped up instantly.

He did give you a warranty at least so be sure to send him a list of everything that’s not working.

Some of these issues may have developed during transport. Not uncommon with a 25 year old machine.