Quoted from jrcmlc:I sent you a pm... But profit and gouging are big differences to me. Tantrum sells some cool stuff and his prices are very reasonable considering what I know about what goes into them. I am gathering that my $65 playfield Jacks are wildly overpriced and maybe not as fair.... Making a profit and providing something to someone they can't or don't want to produce on their own is great, gouging is bad++
In general, I don't comment specifically on how others price items since I don't know their situations, motivations, etc. As some know, I've designed and sell a lot of mods for a variety of games (nearly everything I offer is because at some point a owner asked me to design it). For the most part, I try to set the price as "fair" as I can so that as many people can purchase them as would like and I make a little for my efforts. However, there are a few mods that I really don't like making for one reason or another. Typically, these are items that require more manual effort, additional processing (e.g. painting, gluing, adding lighting, etc.), extra time, additional parts beyond what I can create myself (e.g. hardware, lighting, outsourced materials, etc.) For these items I elevate the price where I think it is worth my time and effort if/when someone does decide to purchase, and as a result I don't sell near as many of the item as I could if I priced more reasonably. Sounds a little counter intuitive, but this is strictly a hobby for me and at times I certainly value my time more than making a few extra bucks here and there.
I know not everybody has the skills or tools to design and make things, but many do. There have been several occasions where I saw an idea where I felt the pricing was out of line, so I basically did my best to copy the design and make my own. In these instances, I typically just make one for myself and that's the end of it (i.e. I don't advertise, sell to others, or even post in the threads that I made one for myself). I will admit in a handful of cases I felt my version was better, different enough, or offered more options to the buyer. In these cases, I typically contact the original designer and offer them my design for them to make or ask if they mind if I sell my version if they don't want to. In some cases they have accepted, but in other cases they reject me altogether (sometimes with fairly colorful and abusive language). Nobody wants their designs to be copied and undercut (has happened several times in my case), so I try my best not to do it to others.