I own an original AFM--considered one of the top 3--and IJ is my favorite pin of all time. But I also have a JPLE, and while it may not be widely considered the GOAT today, I think it will certainly be considered a contender for that title for years to come. It's really the complete game (and you don't even notice the hokey callouts after a while...).
Now...the greatest game with a GOAT in it? Yep...it wins, hands down.