I just couldn't get on with Dredd when I had it. Amazing layout, looks incredible, but the gameplay just didn't hook me. Felt like little strategy or thought needed when playing. I only kept it a couple of months.
That freakin guitar music also will drive you nuts.
I had BSD for a couple of years. Great atmospheric game, but it is ALL about bats and stacking the multiballs. One day I had just had enough of it.