Quoted from thedarkknight77:

JP is amazing, not even close.

Quoted from Only_Pinball:

As you already know, JP gets my vote!

Quoted from chickenscratch:

Looking at your pins, JP will fit in nicely. You already have fun flow shooters, and imo, it is the better game, but I wouldn’t recommend it as an only pin.
Where did you get that topper btw; looking for one myself.
And can we all agree to stop using JP2, JP3 and JP to describe same pin lmao; just use JP, we all know we’re taking most recent. Someone will say JPDE if talking older. Not a big deal, just a wish list item I’m too guilty of.
Edit: voted wait for godzilla cause why not, like 2-3 weeks away lol no brainier

Quoted from C0untDeM0net:

If we were talking pro's I'd say JP as I think the AIQ pro is missing a lot that makes the game great. The entire right side of the game is missing in the pro. JP I don't feel like there is as much gameplay missing from the premium and would say go pro all day. That said the AIQ premium is a different game to me. I've already chosen with a purchase of one if it gets here soon. Otherwise I'll wait and buy one used in a few months.
Can't say what the new game will have in store. Could be amazing or could be not my cup of tea. Since you seem to be ready to take the price increase hit I'd wait and see cause the likelihood is you'll be kicking yourself if Godzilla is amazing (you made the hype thread after all

Quoted from palmab03:

Own both. Have put 2,500 plays on JP. Not sure if I've put 100 plays on AIQ. Just not an addictive game IMO. Many of the modes are too long/boring/repetitive, callouts are laughably bad.

Quoted from DoCPooF:

I have both but I just picked up AIQ Premium so it may still be the honeymoon phase. I love the flow of play on AIQ but i think in the long run I would go with JP, there is just so much going on with JP and never gets old.

Quoted from TheRookie:

I have a premium of both, got AIQ last week but I think AIQ is more fun. With JP you follow a track and I feel like the game gets going after a few paddocks but AIQ I feel like it gets going at the first gem mode. But once JP gets going and the t-Rexs modes pile on and the game has some incredible moments. It needs to be said you can’t go wrong with either pin. Man idk I’m thinking my self into saying JP now… both are such good games your golden either way.

Quoted from Vino:

JP is my pick but don’t forget Eddie..
[quoted image]

Quoted from Vino:

The Godzilla plot twist skewed it up a bit.

Quoted from delt31:

Jp all day
I will say with AIQ - the premium/LE features actually drag the game down IMO. Marvel ramp rejects but more importantly that subway which really slows the game down. Pro actually plays better and faster. Might want to check that out

Quoted from seenev:

JP is a more popular game and likely to hold resale value better

Quoted from chickenscratch:

Cheers mate - thanks for getting back to me on that!

Quoted from Deyanks98:

I own all three of Elwin's masterpieces so far and my JP Premium I definitely play the most and is my go to pin. My IM Pro is 2nd and AIQ Premium 3rd. JP just pulls me into the immersion of the game like Deadpool did and it's just plain fun. The T-Rex head moving and incredible use of the shaker motor in the game have made this one that is bolted down in my house for good. Which says a lot as with my small collection I go through pins typically in a 3-6 month period. AIQ is definitely a fun pin as well but man the call outs kill it for me and that deep Thanos voice does nothing but irritate me to be honest. The game and layout are fantastic but I don't feel drawn in like I do with JP or IM. Like others have said you really can't go wrong with either and at some point hopefully you can own both. I'd highly recommend the Premium models on both of these pins though. I've also had no issues with the Captain Marvel ramp after the cool mod the one guy on here made or the subway. I really like having the balls lock down there and building them up to be used in a multiball. Adds a neat dimension to when to use the Portal in the game.

Quoted from roar:

I've owned all 3 and currently have AIQ, I would buy an Elwin designed pin sight unseen at this point, all 3 have been fantastic! I have trouble picking between any of them.I honestly would take a JP Pro over the premium though, the dinosaur is cool, but is flow killer and imo the novelty wears out quickly... same with IMDN, sarcophagus lock is super cool... the first handful of times, but then it is just a flow killer! I imagine I'll get there eventually with the Dr Strange lock on AIQ but right now the Captain Marvel ramp and in general the whole right side of the playfield make it worth the move to premium!
Bottom line... I don't think you can't make a wrong decision between the two!