The Hobbit is a great game. I've played one set up wrong. My experience was boringly floating ball times. I could not get into the game. Then, a proper set up game was around. I decided to give it another chance. I'm glad I did. It finally made for great fun. It was fast and challenging. Maybe, some of the bad press on this game is from a first time bad experience or set up is wrong. As for the trade, it appears fair for cost. However, if you could trade just one game plus cash on top. That is what I would do on either GOT or JP.