Golden Acrylic's are expensive and usually in the painting isle of Michaels or Hobby Lobby. You'll also find acrylic paint in the hobby area, its usually much cheaper.
I'd start with the golden grab it, and take it to the cheap hobby isle and compare colors. Again the key is color temperature. Some people won't get that but it really shows in blues in this value range. There's a Jokers for sale in the adds with some patch touchup's (in Florida) and that's clearly what happens. It was touched up with a close value but a cool temperature blue and it shows. Most warms are titled or have Cerulian in the name but not always. If your not sure cooler blues usually look darker. Warms are like the sky, cools may seem a bit 'bluer' to most people. plain label BLUE will almost alway be a mix of both.
Anyway here's what you get when you buy golden, best pigments and base, so its longer lasting, less prone to fade, and a base that will level flatter and is more flexible in how thick or thin it is while remaining flat. Its meant for fine art painting on canvas and board.
The cheaper stuff can work, and the price is usually a buck or two a bottle vs 10 bucks or so for Golden Brand. Its suited for crafting and can still work. I noticed when I visited TNT pinball (on YouTube) they used the craft paints and it seemed to work for them, so no need to shy away from them.
Also recommend if you buy a white / black / and blue to mix values, get the same brand. The bases and pigments are more certain to blend, especially important when looking at the cheap paints.
it shouldn't take more than a few drops of black or white to shift it, so drop, mix, test.
Probably more color theory than you wanted but hoping it helps avoid a poor result. Ultimately a little time to test and mix to get the right match will save you the trouble of trying to repaint all of the color to match.
Good luck!