I think you are WAY on the high side thinking $3500. It's a good game, but only a good game. It should be worth more than a SS version of the game being the more rare EM. But 800 of a "version" isn't like the Evel Knievel EM or Charlies Angels EM that fetch very high money. There were still 800 of these made . Honestly, if someone offers anything close to $2K for this game and you are really looking to sell it you should accept. A few years back I would have put this closer to $1K, but people today like to collect the more unique games and will pay more.
I always thought Asteroid Annie was the best system one, that's my opinion. But again, you know what Clint Eastwood said about opinions.

I would not consider a nice AA worth $5k
BTW, I own number 203 of 211. But not for sale.
Way more desirable and lower production that and EM JP

So, I guess the best way to find out what it’s worth is to list the game and see who is interested. Start high and come down I guess.

Seems like there are a few here thinking over $3k, I personally think this is very much on the high side but I also remember what pins cost 20-30 years ago.

Possibly I need to raise the prices on my games when I sell them

BTW, nice AA lineup. Now, that’s one you really don’t see often