JJP POTC or MMR

Game and theme do nothing for me. I tried to like it but found it extremely boring. Not a machine to buy when you decide to walk away from it mid ball.

0

#4 2 years ago

MCB

WackyBrakke

Pinside member

4y 100K 3,950 16 21 10

OP
Quoted from Psw757:
Game and theme do nothing for me. I tried to like it bound found it extremely boring. Not a machine to buy when you decide to walk away from it mid ball.

0

#5 2 years ago

VP

pipes

Inactive member

Unknown

4y 68,800 1,526 11

OP
Quoted from Psw757:
Game and theme do nothing for me. I tried to like it but found it extremely boring. Not a machine to buy when you decide to walk away from it mid ball.

Yikes, that's harsh. Hard to believe you can think it's that bad, wow.

0

#6 2 years ago

AJS

altan

aaarpinball.com

16y 80,550 1,625 11 16

Simple.

Decide if you’d rather have a game where they took away the coin mech or a game where they took away the 3 spinning disc mech.

0

#7 2 years ago

JJH

JJHLH

Pinside member

Fort Worth, TX

4y 65,800 659 2 8

MMr. Great original theme, humor, toys, art, code by Lyman, music, epic callouts, fun shots. I should have listened to everyone and bought one earlier. Have you also considered AFMr LE?

0

2

#8 2 years ago

MGH

Pinballpal

Pinside member

Altoona, PA

9y 66,800 908 10

Quoted from altan:
Simple.
Decide if you’d rather have a game where they took away the coin mech or a game where they took away the 3 spinning disc mech.

MMR comes with coin mechs now tho .

0

2

#9 2 years ago

OP

PSW

Psw757

Pinside member

8y 89,800 5,067 10 40

Quoted from pipes:
Yikes, that's harsh. Hard to believe you can think it's that bad, wow.

Just didn’t work for me. Didn’t intend for it to be a harsh statement.

0

#10 2 years ago

???

romulusx

Pinside member

Extremely boring???

#11 2 years ago

PSW

Psw757

Pinside member

8y 89,800 5,067 10 40

Quoted from romulusx:
Extremely boring???

Yes boring for me but this post wasn’t about dialed in, someone else tossed in a random game.

I asked on an opinion of potc vs mmr.

0

#12 2 years ago

DTS

dts

Pinside member

Bend, OR

5y 88,300 1,218 5 13 1

MMR, it’s great. But they are so different. If you like TZ, you’d probably like POTC.

0

2

#13 2 years ago

DHF

fosaisu

Pinside member

7y 129K 8,244

Why not buy an MMR now, enjoy it for six months or a year, then sell it and get a POTC or whatever game strikes your fancy at that point?

0

#14 2 years ago

VP

pipes

Inactive member

Unknown

4y 68,800 1,526 11

MMR gets my vote between the two.

0

1

#15 2 years ago

KOZ

MMR is a known entity, how many have played JJP POTC? I'd say enjoy an MMR now and wait until you've played POTC extensively. If you like JJP POTC better, MMR would be an easy sell. I've never played JJP POTC but it would have to be the best machine I'd ever played to dislodge MMR.

0

#16 2 years ago

JMR

Only_Pinball

Pinside member

Naples, FL

6y 95,800 985 5

I also voted MMr. The entire package is pure fun. We LOVE ours.

0

#17 2 years ago

AK

Coolpinballdino

Pinside member

5y 160K 3,337 94 416 2

Get MMR it's a proven winner and if you get bored of it in the future sell it and buy POTC.

0

1

#18 2 years ago

WOZ

PanzerFreak

Pinside member

11y 106K 9,637 10

I would get MMR today even though I prefer Pirates. Why? I'm tired of buying new games that go through minor hardware revisions during their first few production runs. The games we are talking about are now $8k-$9500, for that type of money I don't want to deal with fix kits and other early adopter issues. MMR's being made today are solid as they have been in production for a while. Pretty much every new game goes through at least some minor hardware revisions early on. This is one of the reasons I went with a new Dialed In today versus an early POTC. I would get a MMR today and then down the road decide if I want to keep it or sell it to get POTC.