Quoted from Rasavage:Out of all the recent games that are now or soon-to-be available, JJJP Pirates and American Pinball's Oktoberfest are the two I find the most interesting for a potential purchase. I played POTC this summer and was really impressed, and the code has seemed to really develop into a league of its own since. I haven't played Oktoberfest, but it looks like it shoots well and is "full-featured" with a theme that I think is fun.
I won't make any decisions until I've put enough time on both, but which do you guys think is better and why?
Buy both and play them for a few months. After you know them pretty well, if you don't like either of them for long term keepers, sell or trade when the next hotness comes out! 
Dixon, CA
Vernon, BC
