Three reasons TMNT is different than the others:
1. It was originally a comic book, not an animated TV series or movie.
2. The pin is actually based on the live action movie, not the cartoon. You can tell by the translite.
3. It was a kid theme when I was a kid, not when I was already a teenager or adult. (I suppose Muppets at least meets this but seriously, MUPPETS?!)
4. I paid less than 1/4 of what a new JJP game costs for it.
Quoted from konghusker:To each their own. I'm 38 years old, and yes, I would LOVE a toy story jjp. My kids would LOVE it to. I have to say most of the big themes lately are either old rock bands, or themes from when we were kids in the 70's-80's.
Harry Potter ironically is about the biggest KIDS series/books ever. I'm assuming you're a grown man and yet you want something with magical creatures and wizards, but will mock anybody who is excited about other childhood classics? Again, each to their own but a toy story, Muppets, or potc jjp pin would be awesome.
I am 37 and have 5 kids aged 3 to 11. Toy Story is honestly too old for them and too new for me. Neither of us had that as a big hit when we were kids. I was already a teenager when it came out. I will let the people 10 years younger than me buy that for their basements. The only way I'd consider something like Toy Story was if it was really cheap. I can buy ANY theme if the combination of theme, game play and price is right. Toy Story would have to be a very fantastic game and drastically cheaper than any other JJP game for me to want it.
Harry Potter was popular with a wide range of age groups from kids to adults and it was not animated. It is not comparable to the other animated kid themes with only a few elements to keep adults interested too. I love fantasy themes, Sci-Fi themes and superhero themes; Star Wars, DC, Marvel, LotR, Harry Potter, Aliens, Predator, etc are all great themes IMO. It is the combination of ANIMATION and PRIMARILY DIRECTED AT KIDS that creates my disinterest.
Was Shrek a raving success? Toy Story for $8k+ can be epic in someone else's basement. Harry Potter or PotC would both be better.
I will also again put my plug in for Man of Steel or Batman V Superman. I'd seriously buy two of the highest edition (CE or LE or SLE or whatever they come up with next).