I've owned every JJP game except for Wonka.
Still have a POTC, played and really enjoyed Hobbit for a LONG time. Never really clicked with WOZ, but I've owned it twice. Wonka I've played the crap out of, but didn't really want to own it.
DI is the one I'd buy again in a second. Fun and fast, great storyline and theme. Wish it had a rock n' roll soundtrack though