JM by miles.
I’ve only owned one of these 2 games (JD), but I’ve played enough of both of them to make that decision. I tend to keep my games a long time, but JD only lasted 2 weeks in my house. I hated it. Now granted, that was back when were a lot cheaper and I bought it on a whim not knowing the game well. But I ended up having to dump it because I started hating Pinball by playing it. I think I’ve played it about 5 times since owning it, if I owned 1000 games, none of them would be JD.
JM on the other hand is a fun romp. I’m not wild about the glove, but other than that, I enjoy the game. And I really like hitting the spinner.