I was actually surprised by this game. I put one in a location next to a beater monster bash, (both set at .50) and monster bash earned 2-1 what pirates did. Pulled the bash put in a fish tales or something, and at best, the pirates did equal to other game. Moved it around a bit, with no results. It was basically a new game, that only broke once. I think it was the drive gear on ship. I tried to like it too, but just couldn't get into it, so I dumped it. Now with that being said, if you like it just buy it. These things are like pies, there's a flavor for everyone.