Quoted from Liakos:
Cuz if mb was the greatest it would be the best for a 1 pin collection yet everyone advises against that....?
Herein lies the problem: not everyone agrees on whether their rating reflects a pin that would be best in a 1 pin collection. Some are rating it from the perspective of a great location pin, some as a tournament pin, some as a home pin in a sizable collection, some as a single pin in home.
Monster Bash for example, is in my opinion a near perfect game and worthy of its top 3 ranking - for an occasional play in an arcade. At the same time, it would be in my bottom 50 for a single pin in a home, because it lacks the depth that doesn’t matter as much in an arcade. It’s also fantastic in a multiple pin home collection. Same for Medieval Madness.
Perhaps you should ask for a different ranking of everyone’s top pins if they were to have a single pin collection?