MM is like vanilla... not great but if its there its OK.

some people seem to love but I think those people are weird.

Im not even sure i would put it in the top 25 but I can say that for most of the top 10 on here.

AFM which is pretty similar but is miles more fun, not as much crap on it but as a player it kills MM.

JP is a wood chopper... I lasted about a week with one and just got sick of it.

I call them "tourney games"... the games the tourney players love because you can solve them like puzzles and rinse repeat.

Everyone is different...

Scared Stiff and Monster Bash are good games but for a decent player they are way too easy unless you get into setting them up hard (i.e. removing the outline posts etc). AFM is way more of a challenge.

The ratings would be more legit if you had to have some kind of credentials to review ( like maybe some tourney play or whatever)

Half the reviews are people who play a game once somewhere and review it or frankly arent good enough players to really judge what a good game is.

or the worst which is people trying to price pump whatever the new game is because they just bought one ( even if it kinda sucks... cough GNR cough)

In a fair and just world LOTR would be #1.

Best mix of rules, theme integration, layout etc etc... maybe gets docked a bit for artwork.

The only pin I never get sick of playing.

MM is the best game ever in the same sense that vanilla is the best Ice cream flavor.