I like 'flow' games and Stern really makes very few of them. Batman Dark Knight is my favorite from Stern (odd i know). LOTR is close second followed by TSPP. I feel like TSPP is still more of a 90's style Stern game though, even though it was 2003. I absolutely abhor the idea that they take away so much of the game if you buy lesser models. Also, two ramp band pins bore me and that seems to be the majority of their business lately. I'm also angry with them for making GB so un-fun.
Also Blake, X-Files is totally fun.