Quoted from CrazyLevi:OK, since this thread is quickly dying its well-deserved death, let's just go over this one more time for you "no-brainer!" types. This can just be cut and pasted into future Alien fantasy threads. Here's why Alien will never be remade:
1. The game needs to be completely re-engineered and redesigned to be reliable and fit into whatever cabinet is being used.
2. Possible licensing issues.
3. Possible legal issues and liabilities.
4. There's dozens of better projects for a pinball company to invest their time in that will be more profitable, less expensive, and easier, without the legal and ethical baggage attached to the Alien disaster.
Alien cannot be "remade." It needs to be redone. You are basically making a new game from the ground up, with all the time, costs, and hassles that this entails, with the added fun of trying to clean up the disaster that was Heighway Pinball's amateur design and engineering and the hundreds of pissed off former customers they left in their hydrofoil-induced wake. So once again, why make Alien?
I've never once heard a convincing case or an educated argument why it would make even the slightest amount of sense.
Well now I'm totally conflicted and don't know what to hope for...
On the one hand, I would really love to see Kaneda be wrong about this if it means he'll finally go away with his inflamatory BS podcast.
On the other, Levi is just so damned sure of himself that it would be fun to watch him eat cake, so to speak.
Also, I have played Alien and thought it was really cool. Interesting shots and you can get some flow going if you're making them. Not a cookie-cutter layout, and the theme integration is killer. Didn't miss Sigourney at all, there's enough there without her.
So I guess I'd have to say that given all the hard work that went into making this game and how awesome and underappreciated it is, I hope that they do produce it and make it available to the masses. Along with that I hope everyone who hasn't been properly compensated for its development is made whoie as well.
...and if they don't, Kaneda ending his podcast is a really nice consolation prize.