Based on pricing you stated, Indy is the clear winner. I like all 3 , but SW prem is not worth 2 times a Williams Indy.
Stern POTC is a very nice, family friendly, game. I know the women in my house liked it when it was in my home. Again, not worth 50 percent more then a Williams Indy.
This is based on the Indy being in decent players condition at least.