Indiana Jones: The Pinball Adventure
Williams, 1993
Pirates of the Caribbean
Stern, 2006
Star Wars (LE)
Stern, 2017
Star Wars (Premium)
Stern, 2017
Wizard of Oz
Jersey Jack, 2013I have to opportunity to get from local collectors one of these 3 great games, looking for advice on choosing one.
I only have space on my apartment for 2 pins, and I have to trade to get a new one, usually when I get bored with the pin.
WOZ is here and is staying, I have owned MM, NGG, Sega 007 and Shrek.
I like Stern POTC a lot. Have owned a couple. Great family pin for $4k-$5k.
As a collector and huge fan of the theme I'd rather have a Williams Indy. Will likely cost a fair bit more than POTC.
SW Prem I don't like at all. Don't like the layout. Don't like the scoring. I'd honestly rather own DE or Sega SW.
I own a SW premium and a Stern potc. Only 2 pins currently with WOZ being the next pin when I can afford it. I really like the Indy theme but my wife and I could never get into the pin as much as we tried and I just don’t think they’re worth the going rate.
I’d go with Star Wars. Its fast and the theme is great.
Quoted from bigbadmiker:I own a SW premium and a Stern potc. Only 2 pins currently with WOZ being the next pin when I can afford it. I really like the Indy theme but my wife and I could never get into the pin as much as we tried and I just don’t think they’re worth the going rate.
I’d go with Star Wars. Its fast and the theme is great.
Woz is great, go for it when you get the chance. It is has the same deep “jorney” code as SW, it is gourgeus and a bit more forgiven them SW .... still difficult but not as fast as.
Quoted from Rdoyle1978:Indy all the way. It's the only game with that controllable upper playfield, and has LOTS to do. Resale is consistent, and only 7,000 originally made. POTC is fun but limited, and will get boring fast. SW... I mean have you played it? Biggest miss of the last few years.
Talking about resale, demand dictates that and the prices in Brazil are very different because of that.
There are more indy available them stern POTC here and the new pins are quite expensive due to import fees and taxes.
A HUO star wars premium will cost R$ 40 k, a pirates R$ 30 k and a indy less them R$ 20 k.
Exchange rate is 4
so a Indy here will cost USD 5 k, half the price in US
Quoted from Mnluz:Talking about resale, demand dictates that and the prices in Brazil are very different because of that.
There are more indy available them stern POTC here and the new pins are quite expensive due to import fees and taxes.
A HUO star wars premium will cost R$ 40 k, a pirates R$ 30 k and a indy less them R$ 20 k.
Exchange rate is 4 so a Indy here will cost USD 5 k, half the price in US
Wow! Are color DMD and pinsound also half the price? You
Need those for the Indy!
Based on pricing you stated, Indy is the clear winner. I like all 3 , but SW prem is not worth 2 times a Williams Indy.
Stern POTC is a very nice, family friendly, game. I know the women in my house liked it when it was in my home. Again, not worth 50 percent more then a Williams Indy.
This is based on the Indy being in decent players condition at least.
Williams Indy Jones is a big step above the other 2 titles.
And..
You can get the other 2 anytime:
No brainer-
Quoted from ejg10532626:Williams Indy Jones is a big step above the other 2 titles.
And..
You can get the other 2 anytime:
No brainer-
73% in favor of indy on the pool, there is some love for mr Ford pin
And is thr cheapest one to get 
Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/indiana-willliams-sw-premium-or-stern-potc?hl=rdoyle1978 and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.
Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.
Sao Paulo
Eagle, ID