You are trying to pick between two great games. So mostly this will come down to people's opinions. Neither of them can win "by a mile" unless the person saying it can't realize they are both great for different reasons. Your description of them (AFM being straightforward and WOZ being layered and complex) is right on.

Questions like this are easier when one of the games has a major flaw.

It wasn't one of his choices. And I love JJP, I think Jack is awesome. I love Pat Lawlor. However... the first time the cell phone rang while I was playing the game, I was done. Maybe it was because the game was turned up loud, but I didn't want to hit the shot to open that part of the adventure, I wanted to hit it because I was annoyed at the ringing. And that's not why I play a pinball machine.