My collection:

Godzilla prem
Jurassic Park prem
TMNT prem
No Good Gofers HUO
Stranger Things prem
Elvira House of Horrors
Judge Dredd
Shaq-Attaq

I would pick Shaq.

Just kidding. Elvira HOH. It’s just the perfect pinball machine - art, callouts, rules, depth, humor, theme, video package, sound, etc. it’s challenging yet also fun to casually flip. My wife and I spent a good amount of time ranking our machines according to every detail, and Elvira topped both our lists handily.

But Stranger Things prem and Godzilla are close behind. I wouldn’t even own a stranger things pro, but the prem with the projector and uv kit? It’s like nothing else in pinball. Ask me another day and I’ll say Godzilla or stranger things, but today I say Elvira.