Of your 3 I'd go with LOTR - I just find it more fun to play than TSPP or TZ. I'm not a great player so I'll never complete LOTR but it's still fun. My favorite all time is probably MM. And that's my dilemma. I have only room for 2 pins. Currently have WW and POTC. Have MMLE on order, but considering switching MMLE order to The Hobbit LE. I'm so confused.