Quoted from davewtf:Is there a budget?
That was what I was wondering. If not go all NIB with current pins from 2002 on. If there is I would just buy the first 14 pins I could afford and swap as I find more down the road. To cherry pick 14 specific titles would be harder than winning the lottery unless there is no budget.
If the target is non-pinheads you need to get popular movie based pins like somebody said about SP. Causal players will play whatever they are into like Star Wars, Sopranos, TSPP and stuff like that.