Quoted from jlm33:AFM TZ and TAF are great games for sure. May be ACDC is not as good ( but I have a different opinion ). But now contemplate TOTAN and TOM in the top 10 ( they were top 10 last time I checked ). Mentally swap the Williams logo with Stern and swear these two pins would remain in the top 10. You would rather see comments on how cheap the Magic trunk is...
Yes there are legitimate concerns about Stern quality but it often translate into bashing.
TOTAN would still be in the top 10, top 15 at the lowest, I wouldn't care if it was a sega, I guarantee TOTAN would still be up there. As for Theatre of Magic, I'm not a huge fan of that one. It's not a "complete package" pin, which I think is sort of necessary for a pin to be even worthy of mention in the same breath as "TZ or Addams Family". If TOM had a wizard mode that wasn't crap, then the rules part of the package would be there and the whole package wold be complete and worthy of top ten status. At the moment though, I think TOM needs to drop a number of spots anyway.
And no, I'm not denying the existence of stern bashing. It's all over these forums. But even if ACDC was the most well-built, solid, quality game ever made, it's still not top ten worthy in my eyes. I'd probably put it at about #12 though. It's a very good game, just not amazing to me.