I love AS but can’t imagine how the shaker would integrate, or in a way that would add to the experience.

Meanwhile I’ve played at least 4 different GOTG by now and wish I played one with a shaker. I think it would integrate much better than AS.

I have one shaker and I keep it in my SM over ST. I think it’s wonderfully integrated with the game and because you’re always stumbling into beating Sandman, you’re constantly getting shaking even when you didn’t expect it. I just see AS as toybox shakes and that’s pretty predictable. So I’d give GOTG the upper hand as I think there’s better potential but haven’t experienced either with shaker.