Quoted from rufessor:

I honestly cannot play dialed in because the theme is such a disaster for me. I literally cannot put money in it- I don’t care if it’s the best game ever- to me Pinball is at least 30-40% how it looks. Its big- loud- and if it looks amazing it’s just a cool thing-Dialed in gets a zero for me on 30-40% of why I collect and play pinball. Sucks for me cause I totally believe it’s an amazing game. Some day I will play it but I am still getting over its looks.
AFMR and MMR are amazing games and worth the money. The quality of the AFMR is amazing- The topper is amazing- It plays really really well (the one I pay to play has the lights set way to high so hopefully they are dimmable- worth checking). I actually am thinking about how to get one in the house and what game(s) would need to go.
I play a MMR a buddy owns all the time and it’s also amazing and has held up over the few years and gets played- it’s awesome and I would badly want one if I didn’t get to scratch that itch regularly and on the cheap.
Played Hobbit a bit now and again and not nearly the same as the above remade classics.
I would get AFMR all day.

Quoted from brainmegaphone:Why do so many people on pinside solicit complete random strangers on the internet to make decisions like this. It is a game - buy the one you like to play the most.
Also - you won’t just have one pinball machine - no matter what you think right now. You’ll be back for another.