Ok guys, first off, I never intended this thread to become any kind of pissing contest or hostility outlet! I was just trying to do some preemptive intel on my options for fixing the damage. As a relatively new "registered" user here (altho ive been a lurker for many years) I dont want to get off on the wrong foot with any of you, I want to earn the respect of this community as a positively contributing member.
As I stated earlier, I had not put eyes on the machine at the time of my original posting... now that I have, I am going to give a more realistic assessment of the situation, damage and condition of the game... which will hopefully settle things down a bit.
First off, there's no question that the damage is new, based on the clearly freshly exposed wood. Altho I respect everyone's opinion, its impossible to know how the damage was caused, but i'm assuming it was forklift related. The damaged area is only about 2" x 2" triangle. Even my interpretation of that pic my wife sent, was that the damaged area was much larger. Only one layer of the plywood was torn off, so realistically, there is no affect on the structural stability... it's purely cosmetic.
Now, as far as the overall condition of the machine... the cabinet is otherwise outstanding, as far as what you'd expect from a 30-year-old game, i'd give it and easy 9/10. The backbox has some minor bumps and bruises on the sides and because the back panel is particle board on these units, it has typical decay from age, so i'd rate the backbox cabinetry 7.5/10. The inside of the backbox and boards/wiring harness are absolutely flawless and virtually untouched, no battery acid damage either, an absolute 10/10!
Transilght and glass are also perfect, displays are all crisp, bright and perfect, but clearly one of the alpha's were replaced at some point.
Onto the playfield... The game has been played, this was not a barn-find time-capsule, nor did I expect it to be. The playfield has the full OEM mylar and it's in excellent shape, other than needing a polish and wax badly. There is very minor wear in a couple spots that have no mylar, and all the outholes have normal typical wear, but nowhere near as bad as a route machine!
The two notorious plastics (visor inside cover and under-ramp piece) are a little banged-up, but not as demolished as most ive seen... I will be looking to replace those (good luck, I know). There are a couple screws, nylon acorns, etc missing, but that's no biggie, but all the playfield elements are functioning normally. and the underside of playfiled and wiring harness are flawless and appear untouched, there is absolutely no hack soldering or jerry-rigged "repairs" what-so-ever!
In summary... altho I retract and regret using the word "pristine", I am very happy with the condition of the machine (not withstanding the cabinet damage) and I give it an overall condition rating of 7/10 in its current state, and with nothing more than some good old fashioned elbow grease, it will be a 8.5+/10 once I shop it out.
Lastly, I think i'm going to forget about filing a claim with NAVL, its not worth all the hassle, I can fix the damage myself, and nobody will ever see it anyway. I am not concerned about resale value, this machine is way too clean and nice NOT to keep in my collection permanently. I may however, ask that NAVL refund a portion of the shipping fee in light of the damage, but I fully expect them to tell me to "go F myself", and if they do, I will never use them again, which is a shame because I have budgeted to buy up to 8 more games in the new year, and I will be restricted to buying in the southwest region.
Lets just call this a false-alarm, for which I apologize for stirring up a totally unintentional heated debate. Lets all be friends again, please?
PS. I found a new under-visor plastic and its on the way, but If anyone has that under-ramp plastic for sale, please PM me, I will buy it.
Steve