BSD yes

I think about selling my HS2 for something else all the time. I get to redline mania on most games. I think about selling before I play a game............ and walk away after a few games thinking i'll never let this game go.

HS2 is a great game, but BSD all the way!

I own HS2 and Had a BSD until I sold it. BIG MISTAKE! I now want BSD back and would have no problem letting go of HS2. I totally agree with Jimmy above, but in the end its just too repetitive and easy for me to consider it a keeper.

BSD is the ultimate "one more game" machine. It crushes your soul over and over until you feel like you maybe made a mistake buying it. Then, after you have your first killer 3x MB and your adrenaline is pumping, you'll keep coming back for more. Buy it and set it up to play tough!

If you like being punished, then BSD is for you, lighting flippers are the go, luv that LH ramp shot,

Thirrrrrrty Million

BSD is a strange machine, not much to do at all, but no one seems to get bored of it, and those that scale back to a few machines seem to always keep this.

I have only played bsd 1 time and I did very badly but I will still love to trade my hs2 for 1.

HS2 is a macho bad ass game,it just needs another layer of
complexity.Had my really nice HS for two years and my buddies
got a kick out of the cop light and the turbo charger.But BSD which
I've had for 4 years is not going anywhere,I can't explain it but I just
never put it up on the selling block in my mind

I'm surprised how close this voting is. Wow. BSD all the way.

This is so too close to call (IMO) that I can't even vote. Both pretty limited in what they do but do it VERY well.

BSD is the best horror game ever. Top 5 Williams all day long. Good luck prying it from my cold, dead hands.

HS2 is a good game, but not even on the same level IMO.

I traded my HS2 for a BSD+cash.... I enjoy the BSD more. Not that HS2 is a bad game (it's not), but it kind of became a one trick pony for me. BSD has (for me) a challenging shot on that left ramp...and a relatively simple strategy that's hard to execute.

Theme-wise, I like BSD more...better call outs and effects, IMO. LED-ing it with blue/red GI helps it out a ton in this department.

Complexity-wise, BSD is a nightmare for non-pinheads. They just don't understand the game's concept. So, HS2 probably wins in that department.

For the better player/pinhead, I think BSD is much more challenging and the game outcomes more dissimilar than what I used to experience on HS2.

I frequently read pinsiders say they'd never give-up their BSD...I could see a scenario where I let mine go. But it's staying for now.

Might buy a HS2 some day if I grow a new house.

BSD will never leave without a better BSD taking its place. Great callouts, shots, challenge, and music even (I like that music.) Even some of the humor (Drac goes crosseyed; hit the launch button!) ... and when Drac laughs at you when a multiball ends. And it is a major rush when you hit one of the main jackpots... the concubine screaming when you hit that 3x castle jackpot... it sends chills.

Just until you get to video mode 3