I find any purely fan based list basically pointless, sadly these days even critic based list are equally silly. I would be far more interested if every one had their own say top 25 that I could look at as part of their profile. The generic Pinside 100 is pointless to me.

That is just games they have given a rating in the Top 100 so its all tied into this silly system. I would prefer when you create an account you just added a few games that are you favorites. Pinball is really bad for if its new its the best. I wonder how many people rate pins they have barely played.

I briefly looked at the list when I first discovered the site. The actual rankings never meant anything to me, I just wanted to discover pins maybe I had missed. I would much prefer everyone could create say their personal top 25. Then it could compile together people with similar taste. Things like this pinsider shares 20 of your top 25 but he also likes these 5. The whole this pin is better than that pin to me is just silly.