Houdini is really starting to peak my interest. I would go 2nd hand huo, get some great deals on it....well you could.....havent checked lately

I have Houdini and MBr SE. I would keep Houdini over MB. MB is fun but can be like chopping wood. Houdini is very challenging and can be fun once you learn shots. I like everything about Houdini except the milk can shot. There are a few used Houdini for sale now.

AFM seemed too simple for my taste.

I have both as well, and I agree. I play both of those games almost daily, but Houdini has WAY more going for it long term.

It’s all personal preference, but Houdini seems to be gaining a lot of momentum. I’m not big on MB. AFM is fun, but I do think it gets a little old. Go for something a little outside of the box and grab a Houdini. There’s some out there for decent prices.

Ditto on both previous posts. MB is a great machine and new players can have a lot of fun after just a few games. Houdini is more challenging with a lot of unique (and difficult) shots. I also like his harrassing call outs on missed skill shots and ball saves.

With some patience you can find nice used examples, but that varies greatly on your location.

Good luck, but you can't really lose on this one!

We have both Houdini and AFMr. Houdini has been in the house maybe 1.3 yrs. AFMr, just a few months. Despite AMFr being ranked #2 (and for good reasons), wife's favorite pin is still Houdini.

Both are fun to shoot in their own right. But that's really where the comparison ends. No doubt, Houdini has a lot more going on and more challenging shots. AFMr is a faster paced game - lot's of easy targets to hit. Who doesn't like nailing the saucer over and over. Houdini, you need to really think about what you need to shoot and when. But that is where it shines if your in the mood for that style. And at times it's just as fast and furious as AFMr.

But to pick one over the other is really hard - they just play so different. To the point I wanted them both. Some days I'm in a mood for an easy game and Houdini just sits there. Other days I want more of a challenge and Houdini gets the play time while AFMr is ignored.

I'd mostly ignore all the 'bricked' shots Houdini comments. You'll learn the shots. In easy mode it is very forgiving - lots of second/3rd chances. But on route, I wouldn't think Houdini would fair very well since there is a learning curve. AFMr is a no brainer for just pressing the start button aiming for the saucer.

Houdini. Cool vibe (if you're into it) and much more code depth and variety of gameplay.

MB is great looking, but would get old for me a LOT faster in a small collection.

MB is too easy. If it wasn't my wifes favorite game, it'd be gone already. Meanwhile AFM is a keeper and Houdini is on my shortlist. Oktoberfest is another fantastic option from American.

Word.

Oktoberfest is on my shortlist.

houdini is pretty gross. you should add a poll.

I prefer MB but if you enjoyed playing Houdini I would give that game a shot.

Houdini is a fun game, but its not even close....MBR by a country mile

If you decide to go with Houdini I have one for sale with the "upgrades" installed.

Machine - For Sale

For sale/trade: Houdini w/ a lot of upgrades/mods installed Archived

HUO - Documented (Home Used Only) - “Since my place in CA limits me in the number of machines I can have I am lookin g to trade/sell my Houdini game in order to get something different. Game is in great condition and ...”

2019-10-18

Santa Barbara, CA

meSz

5,900

Archived after: 72 days

Viewed: 1134 times

Status: Not sold: Decided to keep game

Ive owned both. MBRLE is bolted as its just classic pinball. I very much enjoyed my Houdini and would probably still have it if it had a second ramp instead of the trunk throw. Its a stunningly gorgeous game though and incredibly deep. My 8 year old daughter loved it but after replacing it with a new JPLE she's moved on.