Hobbit for me. It’s unique in the world of pinball, and a work of art. You also have to really think to play Hobbit well. That’s a turn off for some people. It’s even a turn off for me sometimes, but in those cases I’ll just go play a GOTG or Aerosmith or KISS and get my adrenaline jollies.
If you want something truly different, get Hobbit. If you want a “classic Bally Williams style” pin, get Dialed In. But there are dozens of those, and there are also dozens of Sterns with a similar feel. Again, Hobbit is unique. It also shoots way better than it’s reputation.