(Topic ID: 77386)

Hobbit Update


By B9

6 years ago



Topic Stats

  • 10,044 posts
  • 743 Pinsiders participating
  • Latest reply 2 years ago by GravitaR
  • Topic is favorited by 96 Pinsiders

You

Linked Games

Topic Gallery

There have been 714 images uploaded to this topic. (View topic image gallery).

HOB (resized).jpg
hobbit (resized).JPG
IMG_1529 (resized).JPG
image_(resized).jpeg
IMG_4364_(resized).jpg
IMG_4363_(resized).jpg
No.gif
IMG_9476_(resized).JPG
47_(resized).jpg
hobbit-PF_(resized).jpg
IMG_9634_(resized).JPG
youtube_(resized).jpg
image_(resized).jpg
IMG_4594_(resized).jpg
IMG_4602_(resized).jpg
IMG_4608_(resized).jpg

You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider jvspin.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

#162 6 years ago
Quoted from TheFamilyArcade:

I think your concerns are unnecessary. JJP is well aware of the GI issue....if it happens again that would be mind blowing.

Agreed.

In my opinion all they really need to do is add a few software controlled spot lights in appropriate places. They can still keep the light tubes to illuminate the majority of the playfield.

2 months later
#548 5 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

I agree...kinda...
Stern wont necessarily have to change until JJP starts shipping in a reasonable and reliable manner (aka no -ish's)
Also, I'm afraid Stern may still feel they can ship out the "same ol, same ol" when the quasi-competition is selling machines for $8K and they can still ship a machine at $5K.

And get close to $8k for an LE.

#585 5 years ago
Quoted from StevenP:

My biggest dilemma right now is whether to get a MMR which I really like) or cancel that and get a Hobbit instead. Similar price point, but I don't have room for both. Hobbit is looking darned good these days....

No problem, get the MMr when it comes out. Enjoy the NIB MM experience, then sell it (or something else) to get the Hobbit if it looks really good.

1 week later
#833 5 years ago
Quoted from Captain_Kirk:

The difference is, they will say, is that JJP is asking for money upfront, and Stern's pins are ready to buy when announced.

I don't understand why people think they are entitled to updates just because they put money down on the Hobbit. In my opinion, JJP is under no obligation to provide any advanced information since pre-ordering is purely optional. That is, unless they promised to provide updates at certain time points.

#840 5 years ago
Quoted from ek77:

JJP asked for money at certain time points so updates should go along with the payments.

Why does he owe them an update? Did he promise there would be an update whenever it was time to make a payment when they signed up for the pre-order?

Sure, JJP risks people giving up their pre-order and asking for refunds if he doesn't provide any updates when it comes time for another payment, but it seems like that is up to his discretion.

#914 5 years ago
Quoted from FrederikFrost:

I agree. I like how they scaled it back, but they went too far.

I think they scaled back a little too much on the artwork too. No way I'm getting the game now with it looking like that.

#970 5 years ago

I'm thinking quite a few of those drivers will be used for drop targets.

3 weeks later
#1042 5 years ago

Hmmm....where are the upper flippers?

4 weeks later
#1233 5 years ago

Jack mentioned at the North West Pinball show that Jean-Paul de Win did the playfield art. He also mentioned that the upper left flipper was removed. A couple shots of the playfield art around the inlanes was shown.

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/48529172

3 months later
#1608 5 years ago

I was in on WOZ early and am definitely pro JJP and I have to agree with many of the above posts. Wolf and Spider are okay, the other two not so good.

I will reserve judgement until the final game is revealed but it does make you wonder if someone actually looked at those and said "looks great", if it was a case of "good enough" or they just didn't want to hurt feelings.

Perhaps it's not too late to change. Anyone else watch Face Off? It's amazing the quality and speed of their sculpts.

#1612 5 years ago
Quoted from JerseyJack:

Again, we are not the final say, Warner Brothers is. They looked at them, studied them, asked for a color change or two and then they lovingly APPROVED them. they own the license, not us. This is what they like....

Well, I don't know what to say about that.

Normally, I try to adhere to the tenet, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all".

But, since JJP has been receptive to input and occasionally makes changes, it makes it seem like providing an honest opinion (positive or negative) in a respectful way is better than being silent.

By the way, the pop bumper caps look great.

#1668 5 years ago

The more I look at the photos comparing the sculpts to the originals, I think part of the problem is that the orc and goblin that the sculpts are based on are not only ugly misshapen creatures, but too similar.

If I remember correctly, the biggest difference between the orcs and goblins in the movie tended to be their size and weapons, which is lost when you're only looking at a head.

Quoted from Shapeshifter:

Whatever people's opinions on these, how come Stern release an $8k WD pin with the cheapest, awful pop bumper caps and no one says a thing? I detest those pop bumper caps with the led's poking out. Doesn't stop me buying games as they can be modded but a free pass for those?

Because what was shown was still more than what was expected. Pop bumper caps aren't even on the radar.

Edit: One of the reasons JJP has my money and Stern doesn't.

#1705 5 years ago
Quoted from Aurich:

Can we please, please, just stop trotting out this tired argument?
There's really no reason why this has to be a Stern vs JJP fest. It's dumb. We all love pinball, this isn't like choosing your favorite baseball team. There's no need for blind loyalty.

I agree this shouldn't turn into a Stern vs JJP fest but since TH and TWD LE are selling for about the same price, I think it's natural to make comparisons as information is revealed.

Not for the purpose of bashing but to help each company understand why and where we are choosing to spend our money.

Hopefully, the end result is a better pinball machine for us.

#1714 5 years ago
Quoted from krupa:

Yeah but there's a big difference between comparing features and trotting out the same old fanboy BS.

Unfortunately, oftentimes it seems when people compare features they get accused of "trotting out the same old fanboy BS". Maybe it's in the way they are saying it?

We all value different things in a pinball machine. I like lots of stuff in a new machine to feel like I'm getting my money's worth. Just my preference, but I want the manufacturers to know this so they produce machines more to my liking.

To me, saying that it looks like TH has way more "stuff" in it than the competition at a similar price point is fact, not fanboy BS. Since I value this, I'm more likely to cut JJP some slack in other areas and may use it as a reason why others should give them a break as well.

#1723 5 years ago
Quoted from DCFAN:

Yes, and the fact that we could go through any game ever made and pick apart individual toys, plastics and mechanisms for likes and dislikes.

So true. That's the problem with releasing little bits of information. We get to focus completely on the one small aspect presented rather than seeing it as part of the whole and getting a better perspective.

1 week later
#1855 5 years ago
Quoted from CraZ4Pin:

There have been hundreds of positive posts (from Goronic, Panzer, etc.) repeating the same things over and over and I haven't jumped on their every post.
So no ... no, it can't be said of me.

Uh....yes it can.

"Anyone" might be an overstatement but that's true for both you and Alex, and you're the one who used it first.

Note: Just observations from another keyboard commando who has been reading these threads for a long time.

#1866 5 years ago
Quoted from CraZ4Pin:

I don't understand why you always feel the need to turn the forum into an elementary school playground. And then if I actually respond to your childish attacks I'm the troll.
If others can post their same opinions over and over then I guess I will too.

Personally, not a big fan of the "they're doing it so I might as well do it too" justification because
"they" say the same thing, resulting in a bunch of derailed threads.

1 week later
#2099 5 years ago
Quoted from Goronic:

I prefer the photos for this pin, but I get your point

Art is very subjective and so much depends on the quality of the artwork to me. In general, I don't like photo clip-art pasted on the playfield like Tron or AC/DC.

I like photo-realistic artwork like the translite on LOTR.

I don't care for the look of the hand drawn art on Lethal Weapon 3 (typical Data East of that era) but the playfield art on STTNG though similar in style looks much better.

The artwork on WOZ and TBL are a bit of a mix of photo clip-art and hand drawn but there is enough of the hand drawn artwork to make them both look really good to me.

The 100% hand drawn artwork on both TWD and Metallica look very good.

The Hobbit seems to be a mix of photo-realistic and photo clip-art. I think the playfield looks okay because the photos are more background images to create a cohesive whole, rather than isolated images of the characters in various action poses.

#2128 5 years ago

I think it's better if JJP doesn't list any features at this point unless they are 100% sure those features will be going into the game. I also don't see much of a downside to just waiting to reveal the completed game in it's entirety.

I pre-ordered the Hobbit without a clear idea of what would be included with the LE and the understanding that any features listed at the time could change when the game is put into production.

So why pre-order? Because it locks in the $7500 price and I can get a refund if I'm not happy with the game or the included features when it's finished.

1 month later
#2540 5 years ago
Quoted from 3pinballs:

I love It. The old playfield looked good, but it didn't grab ya. This one looks awesome, especially at the flippers. Removal of the stand-ups to enter bumpers is great, but was thinking having the targets that drop down i.e. Tron would have been great to see as a possibility. Either way I'm extremely happy and can't wait for tuture updates.......Hope my wife pics the LE over the Smaug.

I liked the idea of hitting targets to flip the pages of the book. I wonder how they are going to implement mode selection now.

#2541 5 years ago
Quoted from BoJo:

Are they doing anything to address the third flipper or do they have future plans to do so? Playing at the expo it felt pretty useless and didn't have any distinct shots that the bottom flippers could not make. Seems like an afterthought put on the machine just so it has 3 flippers.

The same thing was done in WOZ and I use the third flipper all the time even though most of the shots can be made with the lower flippers.

It is also necessary for the skill shots and melting the witch.

#2549 5 years ago
Quoted from BoJo:

It's not the same as WOZ since you are saying the 3rd flipper is necessary for certain shots on that game. There is a big difference between designing shots for a third flipper or just putting one on the machine to have one. Doesn't mean you can't use the third flipper but not having any specific shots still makes it seem like an afterthought IMO.

What I mean is that the third flipper is made necessary in WOZ by the software, not the playfield layout.

The same can be done for he Hobbit.

On the Hobbit, it looks like the left outlane "load arrow" kicker will send the ball to the upper flipper which then will take a shot at the dragon.

15
#2576 5 years ago
Quoted from RealityCheck:

Jesus. Its all the same fanboys on a different day. It's absolutely amazing how little can change on this game and suddenly it's "amazing". The rest of the world are just rolling their eyes.

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. You seem to be well informed so I have to think you're not new to pinside.

If that's the case, why not post under your actual account instead of creating a new one?

#2595 5 years ago
Quoted from LTG:

Wait until you see the mechanism underneath.
Top side of playfield might look like a MM troll, but underneath is a huge difference.
LTG : )™

Do tell Lloyd! What do these new mechs add to the usual bash troll experience?

#2599 5 years ago
Quoted from Pinchroma:

The MM mech was a bit sloppy. On mine it would sometimes wiggle loose and sometimes sway a bit left to right. These mechs are significantly beefed up and mounted in a different way. No slop.

Thanks for the clarification Alex. I guess that puts a stop to any further flights of fancy....or does it?

#2603 5 years ago
Quoted from Pinchroma:

Lol. There is more to it than just that.

Hmm...do tell Alex!

Edit: On second thought, don't tell. I've already seen enough to be in and don't mind some surprises down the road.

#2616 5 years ago
Quoted from Kcpinballfan:

Im gonna assume they do nothing but pop up and get bashed. Everytime I get my hopes up and think something great is gonna happen I am let down.

Yep, better to keep expectations in check and be pleasantly surprised rather than disappointed.

#2658 5 years ago
Quoted from RealityCheck:

Why is Smaug a mediocre piece of child artwork and only his head at that? Why does Smaug not directly interact with the ball despite customers begging for this for 2 years?

Granted, the decapitated head looks a little weird by itself but it's not finished yet and I think the detail in the sculpt thus far is good. If they are able to mechanically bring Smaug to life with talking, lighting effects and movement, I consider it a win (even in its current state) and prefer it over a tail that diverts the ball, or a claw that grabs the ball to lock or some such effect.

Quoted from RealityCheck:

How are cabinet decals not a step back from direct-print on ECLEWOZ?

They may be more of a step sideways than a step back. I like the idea of playfield artwork that is more like a playfield plastic piece. Artwork printed on the backside of a piece of clear plastic that is then applied to the finished cabinet. Super durable and glossy. Might even be better than direct print.

I'm guessing one of the problems with a direct print cabinet is that all the pieces are printed before the cabinet is assembled. What a nightmare it must be to keep all the pieces undamaged through the assembly process.

The original promotion for WOZ was decals with more colors and higher definition that had previously been done. The direct print cabinets were a pleasant surprise, unfortunately it looks like JJP learned the hard way that they were not production worthy.

Quoted from hollywood:

Why are the number of LED inserts cut in half (or more?) from WOZ?

I was noticing this as well. I think the troll mechs take up a lot of space where inserts would go. I was also thinking that perhaps there wasn't a good way to use inserts to convey the amount of information 28+ modes might require, so they decided to use the two LCD displays instead and leave the playfield less cluttered and confusing.

Downside is I don't know how they will be able to do the amazing light shows they did with WOZ without all the inserts.

Quoted from RealityCheck:

Where are all the toys that were in WOZ???

I think there are a lot of toys, just different. 11 directly controlled drop targets, four pop up targets, talking Smaug, 5" LCD and the lock bar button. And, I don't think we've seen everything yet. You could argue that the toys in the Hobbit have more potential to change up the game play than the toys in WOZ.

Quoted from RealityCheck:

Why is more than 2/3 of the playfield completely wide open ... nothing .. void.  That's all you could come up with to introduce better "flow"?

Cleary, JJP was going for a different type of game play with the Hobbit. We won't know how good it is until we play it. I'm hopeful because JJP has a very experienced team of designers. If they were allowed to make a game that they think is fun chances are good I will think it's fun.

Quoted from RealityCheck:

Why is JJP no longer including a topper even on the LE's?  Where did the cost for that go into?

It's amazing that given a very small number of neat things to look at on the playfield JJP actually managed to find a way to detract from the pop bumer toppers with that ugly looking lcd.

Why is there simply a metal apron with art and not wooden on the LE version (excuse me, versions) of this game?  Just 1 more step back from WOZ and again, you couldn't even so much as add backlighting or something original on it?

In my opinion, JJP does not need to compete with WOZ. They need to compete with the other manufacturers. If they offer a machine that has more value than the competition for the price, then they've done well. It doesn't need to offer 2x the value to be a success.

WOZ was their flagship model and it needed to be spectacular for them to survive. I wouldn't be surprised if they lost money on it.

Quoted from RealityCheck:

You can get a TWD shipped to you in the $4500-4600 range no problem.  Where do you see the justification for another $4000 (or more) in this game?!?  It's just ridiculous.  You have to know you are financing the numerous business mistakes JJP has been making to date, no?  Because the money is definitely not in the bill of material.

Why does a Stern LE command $3000 more than the pro? A fairer comparison would be the Stern LE to the Hobbit. Which is only a $1000 to $1500 difference.

Even so, where is the $4000 in the Hobbit LE versus the Stern TWD Pro? I don't know yet because I haven't seen the finished Hobbit. Though perhaps not $4000 higher, from what has been shown, the BOM is certainly much higher on the Hobbit LE (invisiglass, shaker, 26" LCD, 5" LCD, RGB lighting, back glass, powder coated armor, 11 drop targets, 4 pop up targets, talking and moving Smaug, three flippers, subway, two magnets, all metal ramps and habitrails, widebody, etc...) Actually, that's a pretty impressive list.

Still, the BOM doesn't tell the whole story. The rest of the story is told by the quality and amount of engineering that is put into the game. To me, the additional value is in the depth of code, the sound content, the artwork, LCD effects and lighting. With Keith and Ted on rules, David Theil on sound and JP on LCD animation, I would say the Hobbit has the potential to be an excellent value at $4000 more than the TWD pro.

Edit: Doesn't mean it will meet its potential or that there won't be people who would rather have TWD pro even if they were the same price, regardless of how good the Hobbit turns out.

#2671 5 years ago
Quoted from thefoxxman:

Yeah. I am an operator with a collection of games from our operations. None of which I have setup at my home.
I love pinball. you had to be the first to call me out for something!
Anyhow I just wanted to give you my perspective from someone in the field.
Is that not worth something?

Your honest perspective is appreciated, thanks for giving it.

One thing I've learned though is to not put too much stock in initial impressions on prototype machines at shows. They are often too flat which makes for slow game play.

As you mention, the open playfield on a wide body machine is a concern. I count nearly 15 shots from either flipper, including drops and pop-ups, so there is plenty to shoot at, but will it be fun?

#2764 5 years ago
Quoted from check_switch_26:

There is a diverter that causes the ball to jump from the inner wireform ramp over to the far left wireform. There is an up-post in the outlane that can hold the ball on the kickback coil.
The code for all this is yet to be revealed.

Thanks for the clarification!

#2792 5 years ago
Quoted from heckheck:

Yes I know the design is set now. Trust of yours and Ted's talent IS the reason I'm still in. Being honest, it is the trust of your vision that is central here, as in it's current form, we can't see 1/10th of where you are going with the rules and software to make this game something really special. That you're passionate is a BIG plus. That you're very talented even BIGGER. In or out, I do truly look forward to playing the game.

The trouble with these early game views is that all you mostly get is a sense of the physical layout of the game. The playfield layout is important but only accounts for maybe 40% of the total game to me.

Sometimes you can get a sense of things you might not like. For instance when I saw the layout of Xmen I thought that Wolverine would cut off the left side of the playfield and on AC/DC I didn't like the way the cannon blocked the view of the right outlane. I don't see anything obvious like that in the Hobbit layout.

Pinball is essentially a target shooting game. Whenever a new game is revealed I like to count the number of shots available to each flipper. I count 16 to 17 shots from the left flipper and 18 to 19 shots from the right flipper (orbits, ramps, captive ball, targets and pop-ups). That's a lot of shots. Also, having drop targets and stand-up targets in the same location will cause the ball to react differently to the same shots.

I think a good playfield design is one that gives you plenty of things to shoot at and doesn't get in the way of the fun, like the examples above, or things like weak ramp shots that return STDM or a made shot to a scoop whose kick out drains 10% of the time. I think a good playfield design also has shot trajectories that feel smooth and make sense. Steve Ritchie is a master at this.

The rest is up to the software, sound and display guys to make the most of the available shots.

The best games also create a little world under glass that pulls you into the theme with its toys, art, models, etc...

From what's been shown so far, I would say the Hobbit has great potential. As you say, knowing that Keith and Ted are on the rules, David is on the sound and JP is on the animations leads me to believe the resulting game will be special.

#2888 5 years ago
Quoted from Kcpinballfan:

Ok so we are just supposed to assume that there is gonna be a different hobbit pin at every show? You know what stops rumors and guessing? Showing a finished machine or tell the buyers exactly what the game is gonna be and quit leaving it up to speculation. I don't like guessing with $7500. That's just me though. Also if the head suddenly goes back to turning 180 degrees my disappointment is more than likely not gonna change.
The smaug head comparison looks the same. The red smaug head was a blurry pic so you can't see the same detail as in the gold.

There's nothing that requires a person to pre-order. I think some (maybe most) people are better off waiting until a product is finished. It saves a lot of needless hand wringing over what the game may or may not be.

The only things you get with a pre-order is an initial discount, a locked in price and maybe the game a little sooner.

History has shown that it's not too difficult to get a game from an early adopter or a distributor (who ordered on day one) much quicker than if you had waited for your pre-ordered machine to be built.

So, that really only leaves cost as an incentive to pre-order.

Edit: Cost is my reason for pre-ordering. And, if it turns out I don't think the finished game is to my liking, JJP will give me a refund - as long as they stay in business (a risk I'm willing to take). I enjoy being along for the ride and watching the game as it develops.

#3156 5 years ago
Quoted from pinballer0415:

Could you order a standard LE with Smaug edition Smaug? Without paying $200. I'm still on the fence with which decals I like better, but I like the gold smaug better.

I was thinking the same thing but I'm just going to wait until Dec, 31st to decide. Hopefully by then we will see good photos of the complete and final SE and LE machines.

1 month later
#3863 5 years ago
Quoted from Cheeks:

I'm curious to see the accuracy of the target hit detection when in roving mode. With a lighted bank of stand-up targets, if you hit the lit target at the last second before it moves (and software allowably even with a small grace period) the game recognizes this and awards the hit. With these drops, once the machine trips the target to come down, I would think it is not capable of recognizing being hit. If true, then hitting a drop as the machine starts to move it to the next target would not count as a hit. So, in cases like where they showed the quickly roving target, I wonder how the machine would ever be able to tell if you hit the target versus the software tripping it.

I think you hit on a key difference in the Hobbit that hasn't been discussed much but in my opinion will make it's gameplay very unique. Namely, the stand-up targets (and openings in the Smaug area) behind the individually controlled drops.

This will allow them to make roving openings where the drop targets act as blockers in addition to roving drop targets that you want to hit. This will probably play a key part in giving variety to the more than 30 modes.

I think the mechanical action of the drops is going to be very cool visually and very fun to play.

#3882 5 years ago
Quoted from Join_The_Cirqus:

» YouTube video
Super Mario Mushroom World has 10 controlled drop targets as well
Starting at 4:12

Looks like #2 on Keith's list.

Reset all up, individually controlled down.

#3928 5 years ago
Quoted from Pinchroma:

Subjective. I watch one video where people are blasting the ramps and the ball is moving fast as can be and another where someone can't make a ramp shot to save their life. We could increase the pitch all the way and increase the flippers to a ridiculous strength and all that does is make the game significantly harder and people only get one ball.
it doesn't make sense to have someone play a one ball game only to have it drain 10 seconds after it's launched. The game is purposefully set up so people can demo the features.

Game set-up sounds similar to WOZ when it was first revealed at the shows. It left some people with a bad impression of the gameplay.

How about a timed game instead of a one ball game for shows? That way everyone would get the same amount of play and the game could be set-up steeper and with stronger flippers.

1 month later
#4532 4 years ago
Quoted from txstargazer3:

I'm hoping we get to see an updated version of TH at the Texas Pinball Festival at the end of this month.

I hope I get my Hobbit by the end of this month.

2 weeks later
#4654 4 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

I'll give you one reason:
Some people are very interested in the game (me,for one) but are NOT Pre-Orderers. They are the old-fashioned-type folks that want to see/touch/play one before buying. So there's plenty of people interested in this title that aren't "in on it." They arent moving on one till they start coming off the assembly line and into the wild, hence the interest.

Quoted from chessiv:

And lots of people are commenting about both situations that don't have a machine ordered. So maybe you should go to those threads and stop everyone there too.

And some people have been crapping on anything associated with JJP since Jack first announced WOZ. These people appear to be disgruntled due to past dealings with Jack and/or comments Jack and WOZ enthusiasts made denigrating Stern four years ago.

So, we get the same thing, over and over in almost every JJP associated thread. They make their comments and other people tell them to go away because of their history more than what they are actually saying. And, off we go. Their response is generally the same, "JJP fans want to shut down anyone who has something negative to say". Which is not true, it would just be a more pleasant place if the people bearing grudges would go away and leave the JJP threads to those without an axe to grind.

#4670 4 years ago
Quoted from meSz:

Got to see TH at Ohio Show today. The machine looks and sounds great but I have to say I didn't care for the playfield protector or the RadCals. The playifled protector just lies on the playfield, it does not adhere in any way which led it to look cloudy in a lot of places. It reminds me of when you install a screen protector on your cell phone. If you don't squeegee it out completely you get cloudiness to the screen. Same here with the playfield protector.
The RadCals. . . . are super glossy which leaves it vulnerable to showing any imperfections as well as looking wavy. I like the idea for these I just didn't like as to how they look.
Glad I was able to see it in person as I was on the fence about the RadCals. For the money I won't be purchasing them! The protector, I feel, is overkill for a home use game!
Disclaimer: the above post is an opinion only and not a dish on JJP or the manufacture of said mods!

Thanks for the report. I was wondering about both those things.

#4672 4 years ago
Quoted from meSz:

I didn't as every time I went by there was a line. I watched people play it and liked what I was seeing and hearing.

Welcome. Just to add on about the RadCals. They don't look awful by any means. I just thought they were way too glossy (overkill). For me I couldn't see paying the money for them. Now if they were to offer the direct ink finish like that of what was on the WoZ LE I would consider it as I think that cabinet is excellent!

I'm concerned that "high gloss" also means "high glare". Did you notice if it was hard to see the artwork when you looked at the cabinet from different angles due to the glare?

#4811 4 years ago
Quoted from DarkWizard:

Speaking of the drop targets. To anyone who has seen the prototype recently, Have they quieted them down at all? I know the one early video with glass ON where they were cycling around the playfield, they were very loud and seemed distracting. I'm not sure what "mode" that was, but I haven't seen it in any of the new videos.

It seems unlikely the noise from the drop targets being an issue as it's hard to imagine them being louder than the flippers and the pop bumpers.

#4926 4 years ago
Quoted from Hazoff:

RobT is quite right in saying at these shows with the potential to sell machines it should be set up to perfectly for maxium speed and flow.

One reason may be that they don't want the game to be too difficult for inexperienced players. I would set it up fast but put a long ball save on it so that people got at least a little time to play after the long wait in line.

10
#4942 4 years ago
Quoted from PinballRulez:

Agreed. But there are a lot of pins made with a third flipper that can also hit the area around the target. That is pinball.

I don't think I ever see an extra flipper as a bad thing, even if it doesn't have any unique shots, it allows you to hit the shots from a different (sometimes safer) angle.

Rules can certainly make it play a bigger role in the game as well. I wonder if they will use the pop-ups to block shots from the lower flippers so that they can only be made by the upper flipper. Clearly the windlance will serve the ball up to the upper flipper for a shot a Smaug.

We really don't know how much value the third flipper will add to the game at this point, or whether or not it will damage the ramp, but since the team at JJP is made up of some of the best pinball designers (who also appear to listen to what people say in these forums), I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt and withhold judgement until the game is out.

#5080 4 years ago

I really don't understand all the complaints about pre-ordering since it is completely optional.

The main benefits of pre-ordering are locking in the price and getting an initial discount. Though I also like the payment plan because by the time the machine arrives, the money has been gone for so long the game sort of feels like it's free.

Don't like it, don't do it. No one is forcing you. If you want to get the pre-order beneifts I think you should consider the following:

1) There have been enough examples of delays from all the manufacturers (except Stern who doesn't announce a machine until it's almost ready to ship) that they should be expected by now.

2) People who are willing to pay more will be able to get a machine as soon as they're out, either from a distributor or an individual who ordered very early.

3) You might not like the game and/or think it's worth the price.

4) You might lose whatever money you have deposited if the company goes out of business.

#5195 4 years ago
Quoted from TenaciousT:

So when you push that button does it give you a free gold ring ?

Maybe when you push the button the hurry-ups (troll, orc, spider and goblin pop-ups) either stay up or stay down, whichever is more helpful. You're invisible after all.

#5198 4 years ago
Quoted from PinChili:

I would be shocked if at this point the game isn't complete (minus more code.) I think a person can certainly make up their mind whether this game is for them or not at this point.

I disagree. I think it would be very difficult for someone to make up their mind at this point.

How many time does it need to be shown that a game needs mostly complete code, proper set-up and actually playing the game before you can determine if a game is for you?

WOZ was at about software version 3.0 before people really started to appreciate it. Hobbit is about 0.4 right now.

In my opinion, playfield layout counts for about 40% of the playing experience. Rules, sounds and display effects count for the rest. AFM is a great example of this.

#5347 4 years ago
Quoted from aobrien5:

Big problem with the one timer from the Windlace will be adjusting the outlane. Want to close or open your outlane? Well, now it won't feed the upper flipper.

I expect you will be able to adjust the lower post and since the ball hugs the upper metal side rail when the kickback fires it won't be affected by the adjustment.

#5351 4 years ago
Quoted from aobrien5:

From the schematic above, it looks like the same left outlane as Woz, which means moving the rail.

I see what your saying, however that schematic is old. The rail moving as shown in the original idea was caused by a rotating cam.

It looks like the rail is now stationary.

#5380 4 years ago
Quoted from Zebulon-74:

VIDEO MODE on The Hobbit?.?.?.
Yes! Could be epic!
or
No! Absolutely not!
Thoughts...

It's difficult for me to imagine a video mode that would add much value to the game unless it took a ton of resources to make.

So, I say NO. Better to spend those resources on game code and audio.

#5455 4 years ago
Quoted from CaptainNeo:

If pinball veterans can't figure it out, how the hell is someone new suppose to know what's going on?

I recommend waiting until the code is in some semblance of a completed state before deciding what veterans and newbies can or cannot figure out.

#5596 4 years ago
Quoted from Cheeks:

Oh, is that to load the windlance? I assume when this happens that ball stop is there to hold the ball waiting for you to hit the center button? If not, then the ball just drains down the outlane which seems like it would suck.

At just about the 25 second mark in the video above, you can see a right ramp shot get diverted to the kickback and held.

1 week later
-5
#5903 4 years ago

Did anyone else notice that the end of ball bonus is always the same score?

That's going to get boring pretty quick.

2 months later
#7343 4 years ago

I was at CAX and saw the presentation by David Thiel and Butch Peel. I think they had a really good presentation and David shared some different sound clips.

He's up to 1100 voice clips and gave an example of one of the modes, where each shot made is accompanied by a "stinger" (video and sound clip). It reminded me of LOTR but on steroids. He said creating the stingers for 30+ modes seemed overwhelming at first but he has most of them done now. He also said the Hobbit has at least 2x the content of any sound package he's done in the past. The word used in the presentation was "Epic".

The Hobbit has been submitted for electrical testing (UL?).

A voice actor has been hired and the script has been written. David said if he wasn't at the show, he most likely would have been recording the custom speech. He said that once the custom speech is acquired, it shouldn't take long to incorporate it into the game.

3 weeks later
#7550 4 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

You will NEVER get an accurate date on when your pin will ship with the pre-order model.

Well, I guess that's true if you use every pre-order to date as a basis for that conclusion.

Still, never is a long time. Some day someone might actually hit a pre-order date...........naw!

#7559 4 years ago
Quoted from iamabearsfan:

I find this pre-order debate amusing.
If I am a pinball business owner. I can....

I don't quite understand why some people have problems with a company offering pre-orders either since it is entirely optional for the buyer.

Things I like about pre-ordering:
a) Incentives (lower price, LE features, etc.)
b) Price is locked in.
c) Not as painful making payments in installments.

Things that don't bother me much about pre-ordering:
a) The wait. (I have plenty of other machines to play, fix, etc..)

Things I don't like about pre-ordering:
a) Game not what you expected and company no longer giving refunds.
b) Companying going under and not getting the game.

Gotta say, even though I pre-ordered the Hobbit, it seems to me if someone is patient enough to wait years with a pre-order, why not skip the pre-order and just wait longer (if necessary) to pick up the game? Especially if you're a really picky collector (there's nothing better than seeing the actual game you are buying).

So, why did I pre-order then?
1) Things I like mentioned above.
2) Knowing that I could have bought the game at a much lower price (if the price went up significantly) would bother me to the point of not buying the game until I found one for a similar price.
3) I'm not that picky of a collector.
4) I enjoyed the experience with WOZ of following all the pre and post production developments.

#7561 4 years ago
Quoted from smokedog:

But we saw this wasn't true. Many of the pre-pays didnt get their games first. I bought a HUO WoZ, played it for awhile, then sold it ... before some had got their pre-pay WoZ!
I'm pretty confident that when Hobbit starts to ship, we will have some angry pinside rants about people who just call up and order a game, and receive it before some of the pre-pays.

I think if you are willing to pay a premium, you can always get a game quickly.

Sometime you can get a game quickly, maybe even at a discount if you're at the right place at the right time.

Only by pre-ordering, do you lock in the price. That might not be a good thing though if the game is a dud and the market price drops before you get your game. Risk vs reward.

While you're waiting for your game to arrive, you may have to just sit and watch as others who haven't been waiting for years buy from distributors who were first in line (because they bought in before the game was even announced to the public).

With WOZ, some distributors changed their early order LE slots (that had not yet been sold to customers) to Standards. That way they got the Standards quickly for immediate sale and their LE's went to the end of the line to be sold later. (If I remember correctly, this was the explanation from the factory)

#7570 4 years ago
Quoted from Wolfmarsh:

Because pre-orders have so far been used to actually fund the companies during the startup phase, pre-spending the profits before they are earned. This creates a nasty cycle that requires pre-orders to keep going.

Yes, but it may be a necessary evil if we want new pinball manufacturers. Or at least it was.

Stern was on life support when JJP announced WOZ. At the time, it seemed unthinkable that anyone would be crazy enough to start up a new pinball factory that would design and produce games in the thousands.

I doubt JJP would have ever tried if not for pre-order money to fund the start-up.

Hopefully new companies can find other financial backing now or quickly get to a point where they don't require pre-order money on a new machine to remain solvent and complete the current game.

#7573 4 years ago
Quoted from RobT:

Were they?
I thought that things had started to turn around before then and things were looking better.

If you look at the timeline on IPDB here are the games that surround the announcement of WOZ in January of 2011.

2008-04 Indiana Jones
2008-07 Batman
2008-11 CSI
2009 NBA
2009-02 24
2009-12 The Lord of the Rings (Limited Edition)
2010 Batman (Standard Model)
2010 Iron Man
2010 Iron Man Classic
2010-01 Big Buck Hunter Pro
2010-08 James Cameron’s Avatar
2010-12 James Cameron’s Avatar (Limited Edition)
2011 Disney TRON Legacy
2011 Disney TRON Legacy (Limited Edition)
2011 The Rolling Stones
2011 The Rolling Stones (Limited Edition)
2011 Transformers™ (Pro)
2011 Transformers™ Autobot Crimson Limited Edition
2011 Transformers™ Decepticon Violet Limited Edition
2011 Transformers™ Limited Edition ("Combo")
2012 AC/DC (Pro)
2012 Disney TRON Legacy (3rd Edition)
2012 Metallica Master of Puppets (Limited Edition)
2012 The Avengers (Limited Edition)
2012 The Avengers (Pro)
2012 The Avengers Hulk (Limited Edition

I don't remember any of the games prior to WOZ being very well received by the pinball community. I think things started to turn around for Stern with Tron. This was due to theme and gameplay, not an increase in BOM. To be fair, the economy was picking up too.

#7726 4 years ago
Quoted from cal50:

Possible but they pay for parts and actually build games so its doubtful.
Why pressure a supplier to a very low volume & distant competitor? Makes zero sense.

So they don't become a high volume, closer competitor?

#7727 4 years ago
Quoted from iceman44:

Speaking of delays and disappointment, in the world of pinball, if its NOT Stern, you'll be much better off blood pressure wise if you just learn to EXPECT disappointment. It's just a given.
Andrew and Heighway just announced another "DELAY" from the official launch of Alien this coming weekend and showing a "flipping whitewood" to now a "more realistic global launch in October".
Why? "Suppliers have let us down"!
It is what it is, am I surprised, not at all, disappointed, yep. Especially since I've been in since Expo.

Sometimes I wonder if these new start-ups believe in magic.

Quoted from HeighwayPinball:

Hi everyone,
So, what can we tell you now about game #2?
It is major A-list license and it has been designed by Dennis Nordman.
It is due for production in April 2015

When Heighway made the above announcement about Aliens at Expo last year, an April 2015 production date seemed so far fetched it made me question their competence (especially since they're first game was long overdue).

How can they realistically expect to have a "global" launch in 2 months if they don't even have a flipping whitewood to show? Would approval from the licensor be required for a whitewood?

Edit: Sorry, off topic.

Speaking of late games, how about some Hobbit news!

#7802 4 years ago

It may be unfortunate, but I don't think there should be any expectation of privacy when posting something on the internet, even if it's in a private forum.

#7827 4 years ago
Quoted from Skyemont:

Totally agree with u. Jack is only defending himself. I would do the same thing. If the haters would shut the f up things would calm down. If u are in on the hobbit then u deserve answers, if you are not, why say anything.

I've supported JJP's efforts from the beginning and I have no problem with people "honestly" discussing and sharing opinions on any aspect of JJP (or any manufacturer), positive or negative, whether or not they are "in" on the game. This is a pinball forum afterall.

The people I have a problem with are the ones who show time and again that their posts are the result of some personal grievance. Topic doesn't seem to matter, they track every thread related to their "issue". Their posts consistently serve to incite and inflame and they're speculations consistently take and perpetuate the most negative slant. As a result, my conclusion is that their criticisms are not "honest" and that is what I have a problem with.

This problem is not isolated to JJP, it just seems worse with them. I've seen people who are great contributors in other areas of Pinside get on some crusade and then just can let it go.

In my opinion, we would stay on topic and Pinside would be a lot more pleasant if individuals (determined by the mods) exhibiting these tendencies were not allowed to post in threads related to their "issue" (JJP, Stern, MMr, whatever). Perhaps a "Forum" ban?

Not only are they not contributing anything of value but they are actively hindering constructive discussion. I don't think many people would be affected but it's amazing how much trouble just a few individuals can make.

2 weeks later
#8364 4 years ago

Really like the look of the new Gold armor.

#8371 4 years ago
Quoted from Aurich:

I wonder how it feels under your hands?
One big advantage to the hammered look is it gives all sorts of angles for the eye to pick up the metallic flakes, so it's probably going to look a lot more gold than the flat style.
And it's different. I give it a thumbs up after looking at it more.

I had a JP with a similar looking powder coat finish and I really liked the feel of the extra texture.

#8388 4 years ago
Quoted from karl:

I dig the gold. A little more unsure about the LE version. The main reason I changed back to LE was because I thought the seaside bronze looked better.

That's one of the reasons I stayed with the LE. The second was that I preferred the cabinet art with the different characters on each side. The third was that without being able to see the finished machines in person, it seemed best the stay with the original vision of the machine.

Two of the three reasons are still valid so I'm holding onto the LE, barely.

1 week later
#8603 4 years ago

The game is looking fantastic! The only disconnect in the look for me is the silver ramps. I think brass would look so much better. I wonder how hard it would be to change the finish later.

#8625 4 years ago
Quoted from Pinchroma:

Powder coating ramps is a TERRIBLE idea. Habittrails are ok as they have a pre-determined path they take so ball tracks aren't an issue. In a ramp you don't want a groove to be created. The powder isn't thick but repeated pathing from the ball can certainly create a valley and that isn't something you want on a ramp.

I wonder what material Gottlieb used for the ramps on Stargate?

stargateramps.jpg

#8631 4 years ago

I like having an extra flipper to make shots, even if they can also be made by the lower flippers, as it gives different shot angles.

I think lowering the W drop target to reveal the hole when making the left orbit (for a brief period of time) is a good idea. I don't think differentiating between the upper or lower flipper would be that important as I would expect hitting it with the lower flipper on the fly would be very difficult.

#8640 4 years ago
Quoted from beelzeboob:

We don't know what GoT is yet because nobody has played it.
TH may be awesome, but it's no WOZ.

Woz is an amazing game and is so loaded with stuff. Hobbit is more open with less stuff on the surface, but I'm hoping it will also be amazing in it's own ways.

To me, pinball is basically a "shooting gallery" type of game. Fun shots that when hit give a satisfying result in the form of points, sound, lighting effects and game progression.

I'm thinking JJP did not go through all the effort to put 11 individually controlled drop targets in the game (with stand-up targets behind them) just to use them as they've been used in the past. Cactus Canyon only has 4 individual drop targets (not in banks) and they really add to the gameplay.

Even though the playfield layout looks a little ho-hum, the potential is there with the Hobbit to create a playing experience unlike anything we've seen in the past.

For example, I can envision a mode where one drop target cycles around the playfield or another where an opening between the drop targets cycles instead. You can create a similar effect with insert lights but there is just something special about mechanical movement to me.

That potential combined with the degree of polish JJP put into WOZ, the LCD assets, sound, lighting and animated talking Smaug are what have me anticipating one heck of a shooting gallery.

It's all up to the imagination of the programmers and the time they are given to work on it.

#8662 4 years ago
Quoted from cal50:

but I do not know of many businesses that operate that way.

Are there any video game companies that work like this? It seems like unless they have multiple teams in place, it must take years to develop a game.

#8676 4 years ago
Quoted from vireland:

Have you done it? I have on The Shadow. No grooves on black powder coated ramps after like 10 years. Seems like speculation of people who haven't done it, based on my first-hand experience with actually doing it. Especially when we're talking non-routed pins for the most part.

Nice to see you on here Vic. Welcome.

I miss some of the great NIB deals you used to offer many years ago.

#8695 4 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

Ill say it again: id refrain from "spiking the ball" on TH before your team even takes the field

Agreed, and I'm an early WOZ buyer.

I think the constant comparisons putting down Stern or overly exuberant claims are part of the reason people get annoyed with JJP fans and want to point out every flaw when a JJP game comes out.

1 week later
#8788 4 years ago
Quoted from wcbrandes:

I know I know it doesn't make it more fun to play or contribute to the all around experience

This I disagree with. The DMD/LCD effects definitely contribute to my overall playing experience.

For example, the excellent quality of the dots on STTNG add to the immersive experience of that game for me whereas the poor quality of the dots on ST detract from my overall experience.

It's not even fair to compare the LCD on WOZ which is on an entirely different level.

Edit: Just noticed you weren't serious as evidenced by your eyeroll.

#8824 4 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

I'm extremely pissed off at Stern for not including it in their latest title- it's a phenomenal opportunity LOST.

It is an opportunity lost, but it's the content that can make an LCD really add value. I don't know what kind of implementation we will see from Stern with the speed at which they puts out games. So, I'm keeping my expectations in check.

#8837 4 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

Fair point.
Had Stern put an LCD into GoT, it probably wouldn't be to the level I'm fantasizing about it (especially seeing how they 'mailed it in" on there artwork).
I'm not that easy to please:
I *JUST* want:
Games with the attention to immersive detail in sounds, music and video that JJP is putting in TH
and
Machines manufactured and delivered with the reliable velocity of Stern
and
Built like JJPs
and
Priced like Stern Pros...
So, yes, I want it to LOOK like its taken 3 years to build but I wanted it cranked out on a few months time.
Geez, is that so much to ask?!?!?!?!?

Seriously though, at current prices, I just want a game to be an excellent representation and implementation of it's theme. I have plenty of games to keep me occupied, so I see no value in cutting corners on a game just to get it out to me quickly.

#8846 4 years ago
Quoted from Aurich:

I took the ColorDMD out of my White Water when I needed to test the beta of Shadow. It was painful to go back to orange. Bought a new ColorDMD to restore it back to color right away.

I promise, I'm not trying to start a big comparison between Heighway and JJP. I'm just saying, Heighway has full RGB lighting, wide body, Alien will be full of toys, multiple flippers, etc. Oh, and an LCD. Which is admittedly smaller. And JJP has more processing power for their animations, they can do some things on the fly Heighway can't. Trying to be fair here. The point is they're in the same ballpark here as far as features go. Different strategies to get there, and not one to one the same, but on paper they're offering a lot of the same things.
But the reason I bring this up is isn't to start a pissing match, or say who's better. Alien isn't even out yet, let's not start blowing too many horns here, the game hasn't proven itself yet.
But Heighway can sell Alien at $6300. If JJP was selling their Standards in even roughly that ballpark I'd be interested. But when the cheap version is eight grand plus shipping it's just too much for me to justify on a pin.
I'd love to see competition lower prices, instead of raising them, which seems to be all that's happened so far. I just can't see the market for people willing to pay that much being that big. It feels like it's hard to sustain anything with those prices.

I hope you're right and Heighway proves that a game that is comparable to a JJP game, but at a much lower price, can be made.

JJP showed Stern that people were willing to pay a lot more for a machine. Would be nice to see something going in the other direction.

1 month later
#8895 4 years ago
Quoted from beelzeboob:

I'd love to have you explain what you're seeing in the artwork when you're trying to keep three balls alive. AC/DC is ugly as sin, but a blast to play. I learned to get over the ugly and enjoy the fun. It's great when you have both, but that very rarely happens.

I'm happy to play any game that's fun, whether it's on location or in someone else's house, regardless of how ugly it is or whatever other flaws it might have.

However, if I'm going to pay what manufacturers are asking for games these days, the game has to have it all, a theme I like, good art, game play, sound, rules, etc...

Otherwise I'll just hold onto my money and wait for something to come along that does hit all those marks.

#8907 4 years ago
Quoted from Pinhead1982:

I seem to remember Ltd Edtn numbers being put behind new customer money and pre-orders being completed over a year after initial release.

The story at the time was that some of the JJP distributors who had bought in day one with multiple LE orders (Standards were not available when WOZ was announced) chose to change some of their LE slots not yet sold to Standards and moved their unsold LEs to the end of the line.

If this was the case, those Standards wouldn't affect when people who had pre-ordered LEs got their machines.

#8937 4 years ago

I wouldn't be surprised if we saw photos of the production getting started soon, but a lot needs to happen before games ship, even if there are zero issues. All the parts have to be in, line completely set-up, games tested, etc...

Add in all the upcoming holidays and I will be very surprised if games get into buyers' hands this year.

1 month later
#9064 4 years ago
Quoted from DaveH:

Ok, let me explain that to the best of my understanding. I'm a distributor and I order 10 LE games on day 1. My order is in and I sell all 10 quickly. Now it is day 100 and they announce the standard model. I already sold my LEs, but if it takes 6 months to get those standards, maybe the machine isn't "hot" anymore. So I tell Jack I'll order 10 more, but I need them quick... Seeing the LEs are sold I get Jack to swap my two orders. I get 10 standards to sell quickly while the game is hot, and I screw the 10 people that already bought the LEs from me.

I gave them a bigger benefit of the doubt with the belief distributors still had unsold LE's they preordered early. After seeing distributors like Automated have NIB LE games for sale long after they are supposedly "sold out", I now take "sold out" to mean that all LE's are pre-sold to distributors but not necessarily to end customers.

In this scenario, they would change unsold, pre-ordered LE's to Standards. Then move the unsold LE's to the end of the line. This way, no line jumping occurs.

Quoted from Krorghar:

What I Frankly Still Don't understand in all this Story, is why his remaining LE orders got bumped down instead of holding their rightfull place in the order list

I think he may have misspoke as I don't see why his remaining LE's would move to the end of the line, only the LE's that were replaced by Standards should have been moved to the end of the line.

#9119 4 years ago
Quoted from DrDoom:

Nice to see the progess.
But it looks like standards with the chrom ball rails.

Hard to tell, but the trim is not stainless.

1 week later
#9168 4 years ago
Quoted from happilymarried05:

Yes like actual playfields being "installed" and people working instead of an empty warehouse full of the same empty cabinets we have been seeing .... :/ i am really trying not to go negative but i mean this is just crazy ridiculous.

I don't quite get this. The photo below was posted a couple of days ago. Those aren't the "same empty cabinets we have been seeing." They are clearly filled with playfields and are in JJP's final test area.

12510520_1108652395820022_7013084657196954903_n_(resized).jpg

#9248 4 years ago
Quoted from cscmtp:

JJP posted some Smaug cabinets on their FB page
Image loading is disabled in your settings. un-hide12510381_1112294982122430_4295440171027173072_n_(resized).jpg Image loading is disabled in your settings. un-hide944043_1112294942122434_8682616700052960576_n_(resized).jpg

If you zoom in really close, the finished and strapped boxes in the background say Hobbit!

64cfce9b5a316d7384f50f41ec6301d8d24831da_(resized).jpg

Ha! Made you look.

1 month later
#9453 3 years ago
Quoted from Jarbyjibbo:

You are correct, I was remembering immaculately. Here is the exerpt from the newsletter on the topic:

I wish I had an immaculate memory.

#9473 3 years ago

Time will tell, but I would be surprised if Keith didn't give us a nuanced ruleset that made the modes worth playing.

LOTR has this and it doesn't seem likely that Keith would take a step backwards when showing what a mode based game should be (to paraphrase him).

#9479 3 years ago

I think the biggest thing about the left ramp (at least right now) is that it adds time when in a timed mode. It also changes the mode when not in a mode.

Reminds me a little of TSPP where a lot of the fun (and points) revolve around not letting the timer run out.

#9487 3 years ago
Quoted from MikeS:

I know in Keefer's past games like LOTR I always knew the strategy about which modes to start and when as well as which modes to stack with multiball. In Hobbit I honestly have no idea. I also don't know what anything is worth while I'm shooting during modes because that info isn't in my peripheral vision while playing. If I score decent points while playing I'm unsure of how I actually accumulated those points.

Did you know all these things after your first 10 games on LOTR?

Quoted from CrazyLevi:

I really don't see how you can compare it Tron, where multiballs all have distinct rules and combos, distinct ways of starting them and cashing out during them, and the modes ARE not to be ignored unless you have no desire to cash in during sea of simulation.

I don't own Tron and have only played it at friends' houses and on location. I don't know any of the distinct rules or combos or ways of cashing them out. I also don't know how the modes help you during sea of simulation. Nor have I noticed the game guiding me through audio or visual cues to figure these things out.

Some games are more approachable than others but I think it just takes time to learn the nuances of a ruleset. The deeper the game the longer it takes. Some games may require reading a rule sheet to get a complete understanding.

Understanding the rules doesn't mean I will like them. But in general, the better I understand the rules, the more enjoyable the game is to play.

#9495 3 years ago
Quoted from MikeS:

I reached DTR within my first 10 plays on LOTR with my friend (who owned the game) coaching me along.

Ah, you had a friend coaching you along. That makes a huge difference. Though I think LOTR does a masterful job of guiding a player along with it's audio and visual cues. If Hobbit ends up doing as well I would be thrilled.

#9497 3 years ago
Quoted from Jarbyjibbo:

I have an order for a TH SMLE and after watching the "The Hobbit Pinball! @ Bradish Street Pinball Parlor" Twitch feed, I have very little interest in keeping the order.

Funny how different perceptions can be. I saw the Midwest Launch Party stream and came away with a very different opinion.

I thought the game was beautiful, looked fast with lot's of shots, and had nice video, sound and light integration. I liked the variety of skill shots and the talking Smaug. It also seemed challenging as people were not having overly long ball times.

I see the potential for a great game.

I also see the potential for a grinding, chopping wood game.

I certainly couldn't make the call right now. But then, I like mode based games.

Do you remember how quickly code updates were released when WOZ first hit the streets?

#9502 3 years ago
Quoted from Goronic:

It will be like getting a new machine every few months

I really enjoyed that aspect of the early-buying WOZ experience.

We all want a great playing game and it was neat seeing Keith make changes based on our feedback once in a while.

3 weeks later
#9654 3 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

His new money delivered a game YEARS ahead of old money (pre orderers).

But wouldn't it be equivalent to me keeping my day one order that I received a couple of weeks ago NIB then selling it to someone else?

How would JJP be doing anything wrong in that scenario?

#9657 3 years ago
Quoted from Eskaybee:

Do you think they will or there is a way to tie the modes altogether so you can have them running concurrently?

I don't think so. But you can choose which mode to play by hitting the left ramp when Book is lit. The mode will advance each time the ramp is hit, but you also have until the ball hits the inlane to change the modes (forwards and backwards) with the flipper buttons.

I like having only a single mode running at a time because it gives me something to concentrate on and the sound and visual cues don't get muddled.

Though you can't stack modes, some modes are very short (single shot) and you can finish and start new modes during multiball.

According to Keith, there will be a lot of strategy to the order in which you choose modes, should you play the game that way. Idea being that the game grows with you.

#9661 3 years ago
Quoted from lowepg:

Who said there was anything "wrong"?
I simply said "new money > old money" , and I stand by it. It was true for WoZ, it'll be true now.

I think you are implying that since some Distributors have games in stock for immediate sale it means JJP is somehow bypassing the longstanding pre-order LEs and letting these distributors jump the line.

Those two things don't logically follow.

More likely there are distributors that placed orders on day one so they would have stock to sell when the game was released to capitalize on any initial hype and impatient non-pre-order buyers. Smart business practice.

If anything, I would guess that JJP may be allowing pre-order LE buyers to jump the line by not shipping all of the distributor day one (or pre-day one) orders first.

#9662 3 years ago
Quoted from halpain24:

Maybe I opened a can of worms with all this being so excited

Don't worry about it. You did nothing wrong sharing your excitement here. Whenever a distributor sells a game before every pre-order is delivered, JJP gets accused of taking new money over old.

If anything, the distributor is the one who could be at fault if he kept one of his pre-order customers waiting to sell a new game to you. However, this is unlikely as not only are the pre-order LEs and SEs numbered, but they may also be customized with a playfield protector, rad-cals and extra dragon head.

#9667 3 years ago
Quoted from karl:

It would also be cool if the main multiball had more layers, like lotr of bop 2.0. It is one of the key features of the game, but so far it looks like it is just jackpot after jackpot.

Quoted from karl:

I am really happy that we have Ted and Keith working on this. If anyone can bring out the best, it is those two. Maybe we are even a bit
selfish and have set the bar too high?

Has Keith even done a ruleset without multiball progression? I'm not concerned and really like the way the game is shaping up.

A friend came over the other day to play the Hobbit. After everything he has read on Pinside, he was surprised at how fast the game was, how much he liked the way the game played and how good the shots felt.

I asked him if he felt my review (below) was accurate.

https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/2016-hobbit-update-thread-1/page/26#post-3075615

He thought for a moment then surprised me by saying he didn't think I spoke highly enough of the game.

1 month later
#9799 3 years ago
Quoted from goldant:

The other issue I'm waiting on a with the factory is my Smaug's mouth motor seems dead. If I use a multimeter I can see the voltages toggle on the brown wire, but can it gets no movement . Smaug is a pita to take apart btw.

Sorry if this is a dumb suggestion, but did you check that the Smaug mouth settings are still around 120 for minimum and 150 for maximum?

Promoted items from the Pinside Marketplace
8,500
Machine - For Sale
Milford, CT
From: $ 54.00

You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider jvspin.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.

Hey there! Got a moment?

Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run thanks to donations from our visitors? Please donate to Pinside, support the site and get anext to your username to show for it! Donate to Pinside