I just posted this in the JJP forums under the 'black sheep' thread. It kind of sums up how I feel at the moment:
Yes here we are a few more months down the road, still waiting... different people, making the same comments about where the game is lacking. Against my better judgement I've kept my Hobbit for a couple of reasons. One because I'm a stubborn bast**d who loves Keith's code and wants to see the game reach its true potential. Two, that I hold Jack to his word and won't touch another JJP game until this code is sorted.
As much as I still love the game there are a some cold hard facts after having the game to play in-house for a year:
- it's not a deep game, there is certainly a lot to do, but it's not integrated or layered. It's broad rather than being deep
- the 30+ modes are a distraction, you only need 3, one for each rune. We would have been better off with 6 amazing modes, but the game was designed around the many drop targets and these elaborate modes that are not integrated in the gameplay
- the game is very linear. Three arkenstone multiballs you play in the same order, you do the same thing to qualify each one, every time
- The MB/mode stacking is an abortion and you're right there should be an option to at least disable it. The ring button is there and ripe to use as a postpone MB/mode button... the critic's cut makes the game even more linear
For me JJP can keep the wizard mode and spend time weaving the fabric of the game together. Give the player choices, give the game depth, make it spontaneous. Give it some X factor, inject some LOTR and WOZ into it...
JJP as a company need to make more games per year to succeed. From now on games will launch with more or less finished code so people like us won't bang about how their game's code is not finished. JJP took this decision to cash in on people bashing Stern about code updates, unfortunately the scapegoat(s) for this move is our game and us as customers. The irony is that Stern seem to be putting out more code updates, ok their base code is much less advanced, but they are improving. After being burned over this game I would say I would now entertain a Stern game where before I was JJP through and through. I never thought I would say that and I still hope JJP act to make me eat my words...