I’ve owned both, still own Hobbit. If I had the chance to pickup a MET again, yep I’d do it. MET is fun, kinda was a keeper, but nobody played it but me and I got tired of it. I’ve kept Hobbit because it’s so different from any other pin I own. The rush felt when playing the mini wizard modes or killing Smaug is indescribable. Is it a long playing game? yes! Is it played by the whole family when others in the collection are may not be? Yes! I think Hobbits will become those pins that were poopoo’d early and gain notoriety after more people continue to experience it’s greatness. My vote would be Hobbit.