Quoted from sunnRAT:
Defenders of the Faith is in my Priest Top 3. Probably number 1 for me, personally.
Funny thing about the Sabs and the whole metal thing. They never considered themselves a metal band, even to this day. They had such a heavy sound than set them apart from all the other bands that came out of the end of the 60s, so radio guys had to call it something. Really it was Tony having to use C tuning on his guitar because of the limited strength in his then recently-injured fingers, hence a lower sound. I'm a Sabbath die-hard, and I do like metal, but I always thought it was a bit unfair to classify them as metal and say silly things like "Paranoid" and "Symptom of the Universe" were the "first ever thrash songs." I never supported the idea to classify them as such. Not only that, but the messages in Sabbath's lyrics gets overlooked, big time. Not your typical metal stuff: "Love is life and hate is living death." Things like that. Many of their songs have very positive messages, but they also reference life's realities. Many of their songs speak to me on a different level. There are very few metal bands that could even slightly do that, and none of them can touch Sabbath.
Vol. 4 and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath - fantastic albums that get ZERO radio play. Classic rock stations wont play them, because they get lumped into the 'spooky evil metal' stuff. Boy, that Sabbath Bloody Sabbath album cover sure is scary! So classic rock wont touch it. Happens to be one of the finest rock albums of the decade and really shows the height of their talent.
Defenders is a great album. But, it ends on a rather lackluster note. The title track is just not a very good song...
But, The Sentinel is such an amazing song. SWORN TO REVENGE... CONDEMNED TO HELL... TEMPT NOT THE BLADE ALL FEAR THE SENTINEL!!!!!!!
I know i posted my top Priest albums in a prior topic... But, mine are thus: Stained Class, Screaming For Vengeance, Pain Killer, Defenders of the Faith, Firepower, and then British Steel... I know BS is 6th album... So that's my top 6 Priest albums.
And no doubt Sabbath's sound very, very, very heavily influenced Heavy Metal. But, like you I tend to think their albums had moments where a song or two might be considered Heavy Metal. But, a start to finish album. No... And that's because it wasn't really a genre yet. It was a burgeoning movement. Where things were starting to go heavier and harder.
But, not quite defined just yet. Whats funny though. And this is kind of a shame of modern music. There never use to be such separation or very strict labeling. That is something that record stores would really start to do. But, in the early days(before my time) music was just music. If a band wanted to do a heavy song, sure. They'd do one, and if they wanted to pace something a bit lighter, sure they'd do that too. A lot of albums they didn't want each song to sonically be the same. That is not so much the case anymore. People pigeonhole themselves and they stay in that very small niche.
Since my name is Diospinball. I'll use Black Sabbath's Heaven and Hell. An album I consider to be a benchmark Heavy Metal album and also a perfect and complete album. Not one bad song on it.
Starts off with Neon Knights. An uptempo fast beat song. This is to get your blood going and you in the mood to rock. Then it switches gears to the melodic, but also very, very heavy Children of the Sea(the first song that Dio wrote with Sabbath, and the song that got him into the band as he wrote it during the audition... Wrote the lyrics... Tony had the music and played it for him).
Then its Lady Evil. A song with a little bit more of lighter groove than most Dio songs ever have had. But, its still a heavy moody song.
Then of course the title track. Which is just beyond epic.
And then you get Wishing Well one of the lighter songs on the album No doubt this was put in there to keep the album from being too dark and solemn. Then its right back to the darkside with Die Young. Just an amazing song. And then they go a bit on the lighter more rock n roll based walk away song. Again. I think this was done to not make the album so down in the dumps and aggressive and brutal.
And the album ends with Lonely is the Word. A kind of hard rock/heavy metal/blues song. That kind of combines all the sonic styles on this album into this one song. Great outro solo on this, and some really nice lyrics by Dio.
I think the album is perfectly paced, and I think that if all the songs sounded like Children of the Sea, or Heaven and Hell, it would have made the album very, very, boring. And having all the varied sonic styles only strengthened it. And made it all the heavier for it. When listened to as a whole. Its just perfectly balanced and paced. Just a real sonic treat to listen to start to finish.
And that too is something that is lost on the current generation. Listening to albums as a whole. They just cherry pick their songs, and so many hidden gems get lost because of that.