I pretty much had a similar issue with my Dirty Donny. Purchased in November, delivered 11/11 or so.. and within say ten games, the board died. So my brand new, $7,500 game doesn't work in the first 20 minutes, that sucks, for sure.
Stern send a new board, it's the wrong board. Now they want me to send back at my expense the boards... seems like that cost shouldn't be for the buyer, we expect a fully working game; if not, fix it on your dime, not mine.
I contacted my official dealer, and he wants me to photo the board in the game, so they know which one to send me... WTF? Really?! I begrudgingly sent the photos, weeks later, the game is still not playable.
Fast forward a few weeks, (12/20) they sent the boards the very slowest shipping, it took at least a solid week or more just to get the first replacement board.
The issue was not just a bad board, but also a bad flasher. It's now 1/9/16 and they sent a flasher yesterday, that guess what? Is the incorrect flasher.
Folks, I get it, this is a niche sport, there are bound to be some problems. Its how you deal with them that matters, and in my opinion, the support from Stern has been terrible.
My dealer actually said to me: "Do you want to send it back?" When I very first told him of the problem. Depending on your dealer, it could happen. Certainly I felt a LOT of sarcasm in his offer to take it back, and was even offended that they would not even try to fix it prior to saying just send it back... but YMMV.
And for those saying its acceptable, OK, but how about the repair process, is that OK too? It's OK to take weeks to repair a new game, send repair parts the slowest shipping method, then send the wrong parts repeatedly? Should the buyer have to pay out of pocket for postage? I didn't pay for my postage back on the boards, I pretty much refused to do it.