owning godzilla for some time now, JP is the clear winner for me still, although godzilla is def a great game. JP is a masterpiece imo and the nod to JP as #1, for me, is def theme as I love JP. I could care less about godzilla and the fact it's that good, is very telling. If it was a theme I loved, maybe it would take the crown.
I'm hoping Jaws could be that eventual #1!