I wouldn't call it awesome yet, but getting tons better and a good game at this point.
My list would be
SW much better then initial reviews, unique varied code that is challenging and different.
Aerosmith is a killer game, fantastic art, one of Stern's best toys, simple code but plenty there.
BM66 had a terrible launch and it took forever, but it officially a good game in my book, an over priced code debacle, but it's very different and Lyman is making it come together
GB I just hate this game. I wasn't a huge fan of the art but think it has some great toys, unfortunately the code doesn't use them and it's a frustrating bore fest
SMVE over priced but a great game and great for those of us that despise Toby McGuire
WNBJM love this game, it just was over priced. The sound and art is awesome.
GOT great player with some of Stern's best code work. Ugly and not great theme integration. Code makes up for that.
KISS has great art and just looks awesome. Plays decent and Lyman's update really helped the game. Pro is a nice edition but the premium/let toys don't really add much. Not a great game but not bad
WWE is a interesting try, just didn't really come together or hit with the theme.
TWD is just not my favorite game. Fantastic deep code but I just never liked the layout and think the code doesn't match the layout. I see why others love it though.
Overall a really good list of games with only a few major misses and several really good games. Stern brings a lot of the criticism on themselves but pinside takes everything way too far.