I just saw this thread. I own TitleTown Pinball. Yes we're only open for tournaments and league. Anyone can join any tournament or league. You just have to email me ahead of time. But basically only open 3 days per month. The schedule is on the website. titletownpinball.com
If you just want drop in play I would recommend Simonet's in Green Bay or Player 2 arcade bar in Appleton.