My '76 Gottlieb Surfer does not award a free replay on points to the 2nd player. It will award a free player to the second player on match only. I've checked the score reels and I don't see any loose wires on player 2. Player 2 score reels add points correctly with no issues at all. There IS a loose wire on player 1, but on the 100s reel (see photo). Player 1 awards free replays on points and match fine. Not sure if related?
Any ideas where I should start looking?