We'll need to take a look again at the circuit that contains the P relay. This circuit shares switches with the primary start circuit. It seems the machine initially resets properly. To confirm, when you press the start button once, the machine resets, score reels reset (some need manual reset), the ball kicks to the shooter lane, and the backglass lamps show a 1 player game on ball 1.
After the machine resets and after the 1st ball enters the outhole, the machine uses another circuit to process the changing of the players and the ball in play count. From the operating instructions:
"The remaining balls that enter the outhole (starting with the game play end of ball 1) are kicked across the trough switch (through switch) which pulls in P relay. P relay runs the score motor. Switches on U relay, score motor 2C, P relay, BX relay and score motor 1A advances the player unit the required number of steps determined by the player unit switches and the coin unit."
So, we should start to closely examine these switches in the circuit:
Score motor 1A switch - blue/white/red wire and white/slate wire - normally open switch
This switch is also used by the main starting circuit; confirm it is clean and adjusted properly; with machine powered off, manually rotate the score motor to see if the switch opens and closes correctly
BX relay switch - white/slate wire and yellow wire - normally closed switch
Last ball switch; confirm the switch is clean and closed
P relay switch - yellow wire and yellow/blue wire - normally open switch
Player relay switch; confirm switch is clean and adjusted properly;
Score motor 2C switch - yellow/blue wire and white/blue wire - normally open switch
Confirm switch is clean and adjusted properly; with machine powered off, manually rotate the score motor to see if the switch opens and closes correctly
U relay switch - white/blue wire and slate/yellow wire - normally open switch
1st ball switch; confirm switch is clean and adjusted properly; switch needs to close when score motor is running
I relay switch - slate/yellow wire and red/white wire - normally closed
Extra ball switch; main gateway switch that supplies power to the circuit; only opens when extra ball is activated; confirm switch is clean and adjusted properly
Then check the following:
I relay switch - Is there 25 volt power at the switch lug with the slate/yellow wire? Check the voltage at the switch with a multimeter.
U relay switch - Is the switch closing before or during the ball advance to send power to the next switch? After the 1st ball ends and the 2nd ball is kicked to the shooter lane, a jumper wire could be used on the switch to bypass the switch; jumper at the white/blue wire and the slate/yellow wire; manually close the switch to see if there is power on both sides of the switch using a multimeter.
Score motor switch 2C - Is the switch closing during the change between game balls?
P relay switch - Is the switch closing and receiving power from switch 2C?
BX relay switch - Is the switch closed when the score motor is running and during the change between game balls?
Score motor 1A - Is the switch closing during the change between game balls?