Have you seen video about these pins on You Tube. If not check them out, also there is the International Pinball Machine Database. Lawman is similar, too.

My sentiments exactly. I know the single player Atlantis is certainly more collectible and likely more fun but I too like the art on Sheriff so much better. Atlantis art isn't bad either but I'm a sucker for a western. A nice Dakota or Texas Ranger would be the perfect scenario but not likely to find one stateside.

Get a Quick Draw to satisfy the western desire and get an Atlantis too!

the best western theme goes to QUICK DRAW that is on the multi player side. on the single player side EL DORADO wins hands down
but that is my .02

Sheriff is a 4-player, Atlantis only single player. I have Atlantis and Lawman, which is the 2-player.

Sheriff is a decent game. I owned one for a couple years. The drop targets reset when completed. Hitting the last one with can earn special if special lamp is lit. Completing the drops can be difficult.. Here is a video of mine:

Played a little bit of Lawman(2 player version of Sheriff) yesterday and the drop targets will reset after the last one goes down. It is a fun little game, but after reading up on Atlantis' rules I do like them more, the sequencing of getting all of the numbers sounds like a more fun task to do.