Alright, this one has me stumped.
I can start 1 and 2 player games by hitting the start (replay) button. After the 2nd player is correctly activated, pressing the start button again to start the 3rd and/or 4th player does absolutely nothing. If I go in and engage the V relay manually it will start up players 3 and 4 normally. I can then play a 4-player game no problem, and when it resets again at startup, all scores go back to zero.
Literally, the only problem is that it will not allow me to start up either the 3rd or 4th player. Any thoughts on where I should be looking? Here's the section of the schematic with the V "Replay" relay as well as the Replay button.