Don't know Rancho first hand. 4 Square isn't the most popular game, but love mine. Value is tough, depends a lot on condition. If the back glass is really good, and the playfield is good, then that seems a fair price (based on my California, inflated pricing background), but not sure in your area. I just paid $450 each for both a Jive Time, and a Top Score. But both back glasses were extremely good, the TS playfield was great, Jive not so much but save able. Neither game worked, but both were 1/2 hour fixes to get basically working. But again, this is California. BTW, if 4 square has a good back glass but the rest is terrible to the point of parting out, I am looking for a good used back glass.

$375 for both is great. I thought it was each.

Good luck, 4 Square specific parts seem hard to find. I have been looking for a backglass, no not a BG Resto, for a while. If you can't find any plastics, and want to make your own, let me know and I can scan mine for you.