I played both multiple times at a local barcade and went with DP over GOTG, which were both on my list, but I could only get one. I felt I already had a fan layout pin so really appreciated that George went in a different direction with DP. It's not buttery smooth, but I also wouldn't describe it as overly clunky. I also like DP's humor, even the PG version in the pin, and liked the "classic" sounds and graphics. Having said that, as others have said, while it's great to get input/advice, it's a very personal choice, so it should be what you like best. Good luck with the purchase and hope you love whatever you end up getting.